Kershaw County Council Recap Council RecapKershaw County, SC

Read

LatestMapProjectsArchive

Your council

CouncilRoadmap

Get involved

How to be heardSubscribe freeAdd to your phoneSupport the RecapSend feedback

About

ContactAbout the Recap

Full meeting transcript - February 12, 2019

Machine transcript of the county's live stream. Each » marks a change of speaker; the captions don't say who is talking, and names are often misspelled. For the readable version see the recap; the official record is the county's minutes.

» a great day in kershaw county we have a quorum i believe mr jones is on the way we've had a great retreat i thank the county staff especially mr carpenter and vic and danny and the rest that came and spent their saturday locked up with this rough bunch working on the future of our county and meanwhile we've got new schools and new parks and a trained and ready workforce so it isn't a great day here we've also got a new granddad mr gardner is celebrating as mr jones and finally i want to recognize damian powell here who's working on his eagle scout damian would you stand up and tell us what troop you're in 303 for the record thank you and congratulations in advance and with that we have a full uh body of council and i ask uh mr connell to lead us in the invocation and the Pledge of Allegianc

» e. Thank you. Please stand. Thank you, Mr. Connell. And with that, we welcome our acting attorney, not Ken DuBose. That's his name. That's right. Tommy Morgan. Do we have anybody signed up for public comments, Tommy? Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman. We have four. First, we have Mr. Albert Huff speaking on shipping containers. Very good. Please. Who is that? Name again, please. Albert Huff. Mr. Huff. As you come forward, sir, we'll limit it to about five minutes. Keep your comments on topic. There's no Q&A, no back and forth. We're here just to listen. But if you'll leave your contact number, we'll get back to you on anything you bring up. It's on the phone. Absolutely. And also the rules are that we respect the dignity of the body and the fact that this is the people's house here. Please go ahead.

» Well, certainly. I'm here to oppose the shipping ordinance container where we have said the first item I don't like, item A, Sir, would you talk into the mic? Excuse me? Yeah. Talk into the mic. I got you. Thank you, Mr. Hough. First, this ordinance is poorly written because it says, first off, that shipping containers shall not be used as a principal use or structure. I assume from the way that was written, it should say a habitable structure, but it does not. It says principal use or structure. When you look at the definition of principal use in the zoning regulation, it says the primary purpose for which land or structure is used. When you put that in the definition, it comes up fairly meaningless.

» It says shipping containers shall not be used as a primary purpose for which land or structure is used. It doesn't make much sense. So, obviously, they're there for a primary purpose, but the law, I assume, was written to say habitable. it doesn't it says primary which which a primary purpose for the land is used if the land is used as a farm that means you could use them as a farm because that's the principal use of the land if the principal use of the land is to sell hot dogs or have a restaurant then they could not be used there that's what it says shall not be used you use your strongest language to say shall not which universal and implies no exceptions so that portion is definitely poorly written and in addition to that we have plenty of zoning regulations you know in subdivisions tha

» t don't allow shipping containers I'm sorry and other places where shipping containers aren't allowed anyway but in like a general usage they have been there for years and have done anybody any harm I think nowadays people look at them as they're ugly, basically, is what this ordinance tries to cover by screaming or setbacks or whatever. But they're certainly no more ugly than most of the Dempsey dumpsters we see hanging out at nearly every place we see. And that leads to the item C of this, which says they shall be permanently screened.

» It doesn't say temporary, it says permanently screen and then of all things in there it talks about you should use a bulldoze up earth berms that would be eight feet high to screen them well that would be about as ugly a thing as you've ever seen in your life big mounds of dirt surrounding shipping containers besides that the shipping containers are taller than eight feet so you would still see the tops over top of a berm i mean it says here not less than eight feet. So most shipping containers are near 12 feet. I mean you're talking about a fence that's 12 feet high. I mean it's just kind of ludicrous and most fencing that you were going to get is either going to be the treated dog-eared fencing which is typically very ugly.

» After about 10 years it looks like it's just trashed or these chain link fences with slatting in them typically and i would say those are not very appealing anyway most shipping containers i've seen with just riding around the county are set on a pad they're out in the open they're painted they look fine they're not really harming anybody if if they're right by somebody's house i think we have ordinances enough to cover that to say hey you can't put it in front of your house hey you can't put it in your neighbor's right next to your neighbor's backyard you need to put them somewhere that's not in a residential area but a general area where we allow things like that so i'd appreciate if you look at the ordinance a little closer if it's poorly written it needs to be rewritten um just give it

» a second look because i think it definitely needs it thank you thank you for coming in tonight mr huff uh mr morgan yes sir mr chairman next is mr stephen lee speaking on shipping containers it's mr lee reverend hey reverend how you doing pastor all right sir um because i'm not very reverent i suppose uh policy and people in prayer i heard that i wonder how many shipping containers there are in the county i wonder if the ordinance as it's written is going to include walmart which has quite a few shipping containers all around it all the time and other businesses large businesses as well maybe that's the primary use maybe that's a legal term that i also don't understand along with mr huff doesn't quite gel with me i am a shipping container owner my brother owns a shipping container that's on

» my father's property things are stored there that would probably be inclined to be stolen because they're valuable i decided to get a shipping container when my theft loss with my farm was approaching $3,000. And I thought, well, I can buy a shipping container and put it on my place for that. I had no idea that I was just about to become disobedient. Pharisees brought Jesus to the, the priest brought him and said, if he were not a malfactor, we would not have brought him to you in John 18. I don't want to be a malfactor And I don't want to get rid of my container. So I would just speak on behalf of other container owners that I would like for a change, a substantive change to be made to this policy, allowing the reasonable use of shipping containers. That's all I have to say.

» Thank you, sir. Thank you. Mr. Morgan. Yes, sir. Mr. Chairman, next to speak is Mr. Chris Jones on EMS. Chairman, members of council, I come to you tonight, not in any of my official capacities, but as a citizen of Buffalo Mount Pisgah area and I want to give out some thank yous a little backstory behind it actually this time when y'all had your last meeting January 22nd my mother came over to my house we actually watched the county council meeting on on tv on the live screen and Mr. Gardner we had you up on the live screen and she said you look more like Skinny every time she sees you well Skinny Gardner was her high school teacher he taught math and he coached at Mount Pisgah High School. She's born and raised in the Buffalo, Mount Pisgah area. So am I. I'm still a resident there.

» But unbeknownst to any of us, she left my house about 7.30 that night. And on the way home, she was going up the stairs in front of her house, and she fell. She fell that night. It was 7.30 that night. When she had to fall, she had a flashlight, keys. She did not have a cell phone. She had no way of communicating to anybody. She basically fell, broke her hip, broke her shoulder, broke her ribs on the front porch. You know, she kind of fell down to the ground. That morning, well, she laid out there all night. It was 30-degree weather, so she laid outside all night. That morning, thankfully, thank God, my uncle, who lives next door, his name is Benjamin Holden, he happened to go by, saw her laying out on the yard, turned around and come back, you know, because he said it didn't look right.

» She had tried all night to, she finally made it to the flashlight to try to signal anybody that would come by. She lives on Fred Gardner Road. I know you probably know where that is, Mr. Gardner. It's not a well-traveled road, but it is a cut-through road, so there's cars that go by all hours of the night. But thankfully, once my uncle found her, my aunt called 911, and we had a fast response thanks to EMS Station 5, which is on Porter Road. It was 15 minutes from the 911 call until an EMS unit was on scene. And I can attest that to, and I can't thank dispatch enough, Ms. Brenda Johnson, who took the call, Ms. Emily Bass, who dispatched it, along with Patricia Crawford and Gene and all those in dispatch. And I can't thank EMS enough, Gerald Blanchard and his crew.

» Sean Powers was the paramedic, and Jade Hoskins was the EMT that responded. So I just wanted to thank them and really thank you guys for investing in EMS. And this is a real-life situation to where I think it made a difference. She's been taken to Richland Hospital. She's had a hip replacement so far. She's still got some work to do with her shoulder. She's got a long ways to go to rehab, but she's on the way to recovery. And I just want to take time as a citizen from that area to thank you guys for your investment. Good show. Mr. Morgan? Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman. Finally, Mr. Tom Webb, speaking on containers. I had a mama and a daddy. They raised me, according to some people, pretty good. Some of y'all might not think so. But at least they didn't raise a little socialist.

» I think they did pretty good without a lot of government help. No government help. If anything, they helped other people. They didn't receive help. They worked hard. And their parents knew how to raise people without the government, without the government telling them all kinds of things, micromanaging their lives. And so I guess that's kind of where I'm coming from. And I'm going to speak on the shipping container somewhat. You know, I like to speak on a lot of things sometimes at once. And where our laws come from, codified customs, written down what people have been accustomed to. And Americans have been accustomed to an awful lot of freedom. And it's slipping away ordinance by ordinance.

» If you want to pass another ordinance, I wish you would pass one against ever doing another comprehensive plan. This is an overbearing, un-American way to snow the people with so many ordinances they don't know how to respond. It gets done again and again and again. And then that comprehensive plan 10 years ago where supposedly the shipping containers were prohibited and yet weren't because people still bought them and used them. There's only one sentence in there that says that they would be prohibited. I would just love to see it go back to planning and zoning and undo it all. but I'd like to see you undo the whole thing and go back and try to pass each ordinance that's in there one at a time. Good luck with that when people start showing up to say, I don't like it and I don't like it.

» That's the American way and you haven't been following. Whoever passed that comprehensive plan 10 years ago was not doing it the American way. There's some other kind of way that has slipped in here that's not like us. And the uses for these containers, so many things you could use them for. For instance, they're very lightning proof. You could be in it and get struck by a bolt of lightning and never feel it. You could fasten them down with cables and a tornado could come through and it would still be there. They're wonderful things and we should not be deprived of them. It seems like little by little we start losing something. And a way long time ago, Daniel Webster, who was an orator and a lawyer about 200 years ago, knew something of human nature and what to expect from people.

» And he wrote something about the Constitution that I'll read you very, very short. It is hardly too strong to say that the Constitution was made to guard the people against the dangers of good intentions, the dangers of good intentions. There are men in all ages who mean to govern well, but they mean to govern. They promise to be good masters, but they mean to be masters.

» Like I started out saying, I had a mama and a daddy, and I don't want any of y'all to be my daddy, and especially don't want you to be my mama thank you mr morgan there are no other speakers oh very good and that completes the public comments we move now to the adoption of the agenda uh it's on the board and in your packet can we have a motion mr chairman mr chairman i'd like to make a motion that we adopt the agenda as presented okay mr tucker a second second second for mr gardner any discussion on the agenda i'd only point out that we're going to have an executive session tonight and it doesn't appear that any vote is required but there may be uh that'll be 12 towards the end uh any further discussion seeing there is not moved to a vote all those in favor so signify and it's unanimous and

» the agenda is adopted we move to the approval minutes we'll do it in two parts uh the first one is part a which is on the board which is the january 22nd um minutes that we had at the last council meeting can we have a motion to approve make a motion mr chairman that we approve the january 22nd 2019 minutes thank you mr tucker second second a second for mr snodgrass any discussion uh seeing there is no we move to a vote all those in favor so signify and it passes unanimously and approved as the minutes for january the 22nd we move now to the retreat ably conducted by mary and danny and vic and the whole team of the staff that's at tab b and also on the uh as required by law it's also also up on the board can we have a motion to approve the minutes from the retreat mr gardner a second second

» second mr connell thank you man uh any discussion uh seeing there is no we move to a vote all those in favor signify by raising your hand and it's unanimous mary and we move on to the next items in the agenda with first of which a series of three resolutions the first resolution of the county council approving an agreement as to road And parking infrastructure and other matters related thereto is at tab C. And on the board, I'll turn to Mr. Carpenter to take us through this, please. Mr. Chairman, members of council, what you have in front of you is a resolution that is enabling the county to reimburse itself from bond proceeds from the 2014 bond for construction projects being done out at CCTC Atec Joint Use Campus. Very good.

» Can we have a motion, perhaps follow a little bit about discussion? Yes, sir. Okay, Mr. Snodgrass, do we have a second? Second. Second from Mr. Bozard. Take us a little further into the detail on the discussion on that, Mr. Carpenter, please. Mr. Chair, members, councils, part of the joint use campus, the ATEC and the college were going to share certain parts of infrastructure, parking and roads being the chief ones. The county was committed to put almost $1.8 million into that project.

» those projects are now almost completed so the county has been reimbursing those expenses and they were to be they are to come from the proceeds of the bond that was issued in 2014 for that purpose very good i want a clarification we established a corporation for that purpose did we not for yes sir and uh does this need to go back towards the cooperation corporation or is this yes sir straight up in front you got that legal piece okay very good i think the corporation is headed up by Dennis Stuber, right, as our chair. Right, thank you. All right, other discussion here. I have one point to make. Tomorrow, is it 9 o'clock, we're going to have a meeting on the joint-use campus.

» This may be a little far stream, but I do want you to know that fundamental to every start is an end, and we're looking towards the conclusion of the project that was begun by my predecessor chairman gene wise uh you jimmy were part of that and i think sammy was too were you a part of that yes he was so this has been a long road to get that campus set up and i've asked mr carpenter to have a meeting tomorrow with all the stakeholders to include cctc and and so on to make sure we we close this project out as ably as it was begun any other discussion okay let's move to a vote all those in favor signify by raising your hand and mary it passes unanimously we move to the second resolution and it also is yep it's on the board authorizing the approval and execution of the facility encroachment agr

» eement and between by and between csx transportation inc kershaw county it's tab d and on the board um with that Mr. Carpenter, just a little explanation and we'll move to a motion. Mr. Chairman, this relates to the town of Elgin and the building of a new restaurant and the tying in of that restaurant to the county sewer system by which we must secure an encroachment from the CSX Railroad, which part of their right-of-way is affected. Very good. I see we have our illustrious mayor here and Elgin News. Can we have a motion to so approve, please? So may. Mr.

» Connell, is your district a second? second for mr tucker any discussion it looks straightforward with that uh we'll move to a vote all those in favor so signify and it's unanimous we move now to the third resolution by kershaw county council consenting to a sublease by and between central carolina technical college and kershaw county chamber and i think we have the chamber represented here tonight too i think the president's here kim uh mr uh mr carpenter can you take us through this please mr chairman members of council as you recall several meetings ago the council amended the intergovernmental agreement between the college and the county in order to allow uses of the facility there that would not be explicitly educational in nature this is the next step which is actually approving the su

» blease between the college and the chamber of commerce for that property that was formerly used by the county all right can we have a motion to approve mr tucker and i will give you a second mr bozard thank you uh any discussion it's uh to me it's just wonderful to see the staff move through these complicated uh things with such clarity so we can vote on them very very easily these are important though they're quickly dispatched and they're quickly dispatched because the staff's done their work uh any further discussion uh seeing there is none well let's move to a vote all those in favor so signify and it's unanimous and mary we passed all three resolutions. We move now to a series of ordinances. I believe there's only one. I think it's on the board.

» It's the second reading of an ordinance by Kershaw County to amend the county unified code of zoning and land development regulations for the accessory structures and uses. It's at tab F and on the board. I believe this is placed on the agenda by Mr. Bozar. Do you have the right, the honor, please, sir? Thank you very much. I make the motion that we approve second reading of the ordinance to establish the containers. And can we have a second to place it in play for discussion? Second. Second from Mr. Tucker. Mr. Bozar, do you want to have a few words? Yes. This ordinance originally, no one in Kershaw County could have containers in their yards. We tried to amend it so they could have containers.

» Anybody that had containers in the yard had them illegally and we're trying to fix this so now at this time i'm going to turn it over to mr tucker who has an amendment to this mr tucker you want to make the amendment yes sir if i may um mr chair um and thank you mr bozart at this time i um hereby make a motion that the ordinance to amend the kershaw county unified code of zoning and land development regulations zldr section 3.25 to amend the regulations for accessory structures and use be amended as follows the title of the ordinance should read an ordinance to amend the kershaw county unified code of zoning and land development regulations section 3.25 to amend the regulations for accessory structures and use the first whereas paragraph remove entirely the second whereas paragraph removed

» from the word unanimously. The third paragraph be amended to read whereas Kershaw County Council wishes to amend the Unified Code of Zoning and Land Development Regulations and the second amendment section of 3.2.5-3 location of accessory structures which adds shipping containers be removed entirely. That is my motion. Very good. Can we have a second? Second. Second from Mr. Bozard. Would you lead us in discussion, Mr. Tucker? Yes, sir. We've struggled with this, and I just want to make sure that the public understand what we did last council meeting was part of the right step to follow up in this meeting. And so what we're trying to do is make it where folks aren't in violation of this law and then eventually have planning and zoning go back to reassess what is there.

» Does it need to be an ordinance or does it need to be rewritten or whatever the case may be? Very good. Mr. Bozart, you have a second. Yes. Just to make it clear, Mr. Tucker, would you explain in good and simple language that we are eliminating all containers from the ordinance period? Yes, sir. We're deleting the shipping containers from the ordinance. Thank you. Mr. Jones, you helped out. Do you want to have anything to say? Go after me. Why is that? All right. I want to hear what he has to say. I know he has to come up. All right. Mr. Connell? Thank you very much. Let me just say this. This comment was made. This was put on the agenda because it needed to be done. No, it did not need to be done. I voted against it 10 years ago. I voted against it last week.

» We have planning and zoning rules and regulations that govern structures and yards. And shipping containers can also be held under that umbrella. However, Vice Chairman Tucker did call me. He did ask me would I co-sponsor this amendment with him. I said, well, let's have some clear language about it. What do you want to do? And he explained it to me. So I do support this tonight because you're striking it from the books. And you're sending it back to planning and zoning.

» And I was told by staff that if this wasn't council-driven, they would have never pushed this before county council because they didn't see the need for it so that i have some issues with it and uh i certainly will be supporting your amendment tonight mr tucker because it does strike it from the books it'll take you back to planning and zoning and i hope that planning and zoning will use some good common sense and not try to just create more bureaucracy for the folks of kershaw county thank you so much for your time thank you for your support other comments uh mr bozart yes some sometimes in And working with these ordinances, the old saying is you got to go around your elbow to get up to your shoulder or something like that, which it was.

» And sometimes it don't think like we're getting there, but we're trying to get there. And there's no straight line. We've got to do other things to get something done. Thank you. Other comments? Okay, David. I just wanted to thank you, Mr. Tucker and Mr. Jones, for working on this. As I said two weeks ago in the meeting on the 22nd, I've seconded Mr. Bozard's original motion because I felt like it was important to get this on the floor, to have a conversation about it. Because just to be clear, everybody who had a shipping container was out of code. And I felt really bad about my friend, Pastor Steve Lee, being a malfactor. I mean, really, it kept me up. He even got assured about it.

» So I felt last week, or two weeks ago, that it was a move that put us in the right direction to have a conversation about this, to allow the public to come and to comment on it. And I believe this motion, this amendment, just further helps us take care of cleaning up some ordinances that need to be looked at again. So thanks for your work. Comments? Mr. Connell. I've formulated the questions now. So, I'm looking at Section 3.5.2-1, and it also talks about shipping containers. So, I anticipate we might, and I've downloaded the most recent version we have online, so I anticipate we might have another amendment coming for third reading, and this is talking about screening.

» The language kind of makes it apply and kind of doesn't, but it's enough that it's a question and it's talking specifically about shipping containers. I opposed the ordinance on first reading because it was, to be honest, just confusing. as as the books had it you could have your house as a shipping container if it met the building codes but you couldn't use it as a an accessory structure or for storage and then what we read on first reading was you can have it as a accessory structure for storage but not as a house um so now i actually like what we have tonight removing further restriction on shipping containers you could still use it as a primary residence if you wanted to um heck of the strongest things out there on the market if you want to put the money into bringing them up to buildin

» g code and standards. I've got a friend in Charleston who has a shipping container house. It's absolutely beautiful and it's probably the most hurricane-proof thing down there. But I think we probably need a little bit more comprehensive look at shipping containers in the ZLDR overall because we have other ordinances, or at least one that I've found that speaks to it and talks about screening, which is kind of inconsistent, I think, with the comments I've heard tonight of we just want to remove shipping containers uh one point of clarification for me so if we were if we remove this restriction tonight if this motion passes um would setback still apply to shipping containers and that's up for whoever wants to answer it whether it's planning a zoning or or bigger attorney yeah well let's ask

» mr connelly to come on up mike from my understanding and we talked it over a little bit with the attorney um once you remove that language there will be no regulations of the shipping container okay so the hypothetical i would be concerned with is if between now and i understand somebody might want to send this back to planning and zoning the commission for maybe a more detailed look at shipping containers if between now and then somebody puts a shipping container right on their property line within what would be considered a typical setback for an accessory structure would they then be grandfathered or a non-conforming use if we passed a code later on, say it's in two months or three months, we go through multiple readings, would that be a grandfathered use? And then you'd have this shippi

» ng container that would be in a traditional setback? Sure. In order for it to count as a non-conforming issue, which is synonymous with grandfathering, it would have to be legal at some point in time. So if we required a permit or however that would be, if we just did not regulate them and one day we decided to start regulate them my assumption would be it would be a grandfathering or non-conforming issue yeah so that's a concern for me if it could be stuck in a setback area because we're totally taking away all restrictions at least beforehand it was considered somewhat of an accessory structure and setbacks or something else would would apply we had some way to say you can't just set it on you can't sit a uh 40 foot long 12 foot high shipping container on your neighbor's property line um

» so anyway i'm willing to support it tonight but i think by third reading we got to do some more work to make sure it's it's in line with uh maybe other hypotheticals but at least the one i mentioned tonight and then also so that we can address um section 3.5 2-1 screening storage containers yeah those are the questions i had okay mr bozard i'll come to you uh mr connolly unless the building codes has changed you can't use setbacks to put buildings on build on anything else has something changed in that well that's if we required it to be a building we're not if we just unregulate them we're not we're not categorizing them as a building so they would be able to be put anywhere they could be put in the road I mean we wouldn't have any jurisdiction well setbacks is setbacks you can't build in

» them right there there are you're not you can't build in a setback we can't put containers in setbacks you don't well we wouldn't be regulating those particular structures I shouldn't say structures those elements we wouldn't be regulating it. I'd be happy to respond if I might, Mr. Chairman. Then I'll respond after you. If it be helpful, I think the issue here is these would be buildings with no name, basically. I mean, we would call them shipping containers, but our code wouldn't really call them anything. And it'd be like just setting something there. You don't have to build a pad. You don't have to pour a footing. You don't have to do anything that requires a permit to back a truck up and set it down in a particular area. So I guess... It would just be personal property. Yeah.

» From my comments i hope what you're getting is at least setbacks should apply to shipping containers at least that that's uh an interesting point and we we should take that up with the staff let's have a review of that okay uh mr gardner was next up i'm just gonna say don't some of the subdivisions self-govern themselves with covenants and things like that would that not apply to some of these things as well well the conversation we had was before now they were regulated so most people didn't put these particular things in the covenants so i mean i mean it certainly won't apply to most of the county but in some subdivisions and things as they put in certain things such as square footage and things like that when you build a house i mean i'm just saying would they not apply in some cases but

» i mean what you're saying is that since this was not in there maybe they didn't put this in that's a covenant yeah i don't remember too many covenants that came through addressing particular shipping containers because shipping containers were were outlawed in our and it's to begin with yep very good thank you uh jimmy please sir well i just don't buy any of this you know we regulate what we want to regulate mr conley you know there's there's a lot of ordinances restrictions on the books as we speak now um you about have to have permission from the government to go out and use the bathroom in your backyard and i just don't buy i think it's a convenient thing to say to try to get more regulation well we can't enforce that now under the existing regulation we're going to need new regulation w

» hen i believe and i i'm going to ask the county attorney to study this and get back with us that and because i know i'm right on this even if they come back and disagree with me bottom line is we have so many zoning issues going on right now on the books you can't tell me that you could not that you're gonna let somebody put stacks of shipping containers out there and there's not going to be any body from planning zone going out there and investigating looking at it and using the existing codes to make sure that they're doing what folks would have to do with existing laws but um i think this is government one-on-one at its best and to me it's sad thank you let me see if i can capture i think we've got two taskings for the staff before we come back in one i'm very clear about from mr connell

» on setbacks Mr. Jones, could you formulate what it is you wanted the staff to do there? I thought I said it pretty clearly. I just want to understand it, so I got it. Go ahead. You put any structure on a piece of property, planning, zoning, heads, codes, they have laws on the books right now that they go out and enforce, and I just don't buy it that someone can put a shipping container, that we've got to specifically say shipping container. I just don't buy that. I think I interpret what you said to be the same thing that Mr. Connell said. Look at the setback regulation and see how that applies. That's a specific case. Is that satisfactory, Jimmy? I'm just trying to understand. Do you understand what I'm talking about, Mr.

» Conley? I'll go for, I mean, I'll research anything you need me to do to bring back. We've had some preliminary discussions about this. Just from my layman's reading of it, once you deregulate it, we won't have the ability to regulate it unless I'm told otherwise by our attorneys. Let's see. That's the point that Mr. Connell said. So we're back to Mr. Connell's point. And I'd like to support Mr. Connell's point. Jimmy, is that all right? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. If I may, I would like to ask the county attorney to take this under consideration, look at it, and formulate an opinion and give it to us. Okay. One more thing, please. Go ahead, Mr. Bozeman. Would you mind going over your point again, please? Apparently, I didn't understand it. Which one? The setback.

» As I read the definitions, if I might, Mr. Chairman, as I read the definitions and applications of what we say can't be in a setback area or can't be in any particular area, by removing this regulation, we might run the risk of taking shipping containers out of that definition, if that makes sense. So, we do say, to Mr. Jones' point, we do say certain things can't be in a setback area. And if we make this change, as it's been suggested tonight, and it goes through third reading, I'm suggesting we need to look at it closely so we don't run the risk of just not having shipping containers defined in such a way that you can say, oh, that violates one of the setback requirements.

» Because I think that would be a terrible result to be in a densely -- say you're in a densely zoned and densely populated subdivision, and somebody decides they want to get a shipping container. And I understand this might be an outlandish hypothetical, but you have to run with me a little bit because that's my profession. I have to try to mitigate risk in what I do. And you run the risk of someone having a 15- to 20-foot setback for their house in a very densely zoned area, and if shipping containers aren't addressed, they could put a shipping container right next to the house and not touch the property line but be two inches away from it And too bad. We removed our regulation, and setback definition didn't apply.

» The way the law is written now, setbacks, those inspectors that he's got working in his office, will go out there, and if they see him set back, they're going to have to make him move it. You cannot put anything in a setback. Okay, I think we got that, Mr. Bozard. And I think if there's more energy on this, I'd sure like to be able to ask the staff to answer these questions, as you've heard. All right? And we need a legal opinion as well. I find myself in the same court with Mr. Connell that we need specificity because we already have regulations that might apply here, and I wouldn't ask you, Mr. Connelly, to stand up here and make a matter on the record when you're not informed by a good piece of study of all the material, okay? Mr. Jones. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. As Mr.

» Connell stated, the issue I brought up, or the issue he brought up, might be of concern. So Mr. Connell is an attorney, and he doesn't even have a clear reading of it. I seem to think that there are ordinances on the books that they can enforce if they want to enforce them. And I'm glad that we're going to ask the county attorney to look at it, and I'll be glad to help you in any way I can. I would suggest to you that the county attorney's input is essential, but Mr. Carpenter will decide how that be done as a staff matter. But I certainly agree. It was a joke. I'm sure. Mr. Snodgrass. Question.

» On your original, on your motion, did you specify, because I know in the written part, that we would direct staff to take it to zoning commission for them to look at again to come back for advice? Is that correct? That's not in my motion tonight. My amendment tonight was just to amend it as I read it, but I gave you that portion that I will introduce on a motion at third reading and public hearing next meeting. I'm ready to call the question, gentlemen, unless you have another question. Just quickly, I mean, Mr. Connell's remarks does make us think, and this is how county government works. This is why we have three readings to ask these questions because I think about in my district, you know, if you're RD1, RD2, GD, or MRD, I mean, if you want a container, that's great. That's fine.

» That's where Mr. Steve is zoned at. But a lot of East Camden, what I represent is RD10, RD15, RD20. And this is a densely populated area where you just wouldn't have room to put a shipping container. Some places you would. So I am a little, I guess a little hesitant knowing that if we strike this, then it's, I mean, it's Wild West. I mean, no holds barred. Go for it. I'm just thinking out loud at this point. I know that's probably, you know, so. Well, we've got a step action. Mr. Connell, give him something. Yeah, I think, are you through with his question? Yeah. Yes, sir. But I just want to make one point, Mr. Chairman. What we're doing tonight does not remove the ordinance that's on the book. So we still got chance by next reading to address any of these concerns.

» I mean, it's still against the law, against code right now, because we have not had a third reading in a public hearing yet. So it's not like everybody's going to go haywire. the problem comes in and concerns is once we do third reading and by the time we wait for planning is only come back to us the problems that may come in between that time period but tonight we just need to move forward okay uh mr jones thank you mr chairman council's not aggressed let me just say this that you know hoas are out there in a lot of these subdivisions they have them and they can enforce them through that and i also say i also say that i also say they can be enforced through that or they can establish one and then two we have ordinances on the books that i just believe that i have no fear of them going wild

» personally and just becoming some kind of epidemic within the county so uh having said that i'm going to certainly support mr tucker's amendment i think it's the right thing to do are y'all ready to call the question i have just one comment one more question no just a comment that will clarify and it's really credit mr conley i think he summed up what i'm trying to say the best uh as we stew on this between now and next reading that on some level you would start to consider shipping containers as personal property it could be a little tiny baby size shipping container it could be a big old shipping container but it might be treated as personal property and we what he's saying is we may not have regulations that apply to personal property being set in setbacks okay okay very good we have a m

» otion uh first and second and we now have to move to a vote to the amendment to the to the original motion all those in favor of the amendment so signify and the amendment passes unanimously with some work with some homework we now have to move to the amendment to the motion as amended and all those in favor of the motion as amended so signify and it's unanimous and thank you general and that was an excellent dialogue and i think we learned a few things yes uh we move now and it moves on to a third reading as amended mary i hope you got all that verbatim right all right and that's where it's a messy business but we're getting it done uh we move now to new business we have four items under new business the first one item number one should be up there it is uh quotes for new fire service truc

» ks at tab g all right mr carpenter do your magic mr chairman chairman members of council you have in front of you tonight for your approval uh the purchase of two fire trucks these fire trucks were approved and included in the 2019 budget that we're curling in uh the specs have been vetted and approved the delivery of these trucks will be within 90 to 120 days and the departments will be the beneficiaries as cassette and westville excellent all right can we have a motion to approve make a motion that we approve the lowest bid mr tucker a second second second for mr snodgrass discussion who can be against fire trucks all right all those in favor signify by raising your hand and it's unanimous i always wanted to be a fireman number two uh the second one is uh the outcome we have kyle kelly he

» re thank you uh outcome of the 2019 2020 uh retreat We did last week, and we have the goals and objectives here at Tab H. A little bit of housekeeping first. If any of you wish to amend a single goal or objective, we're going to do it one at a time, not by block. If you want to change a period or paragraph or split infinitive and there's at least one, you can do that. But the point here is if you wish to amend this, we'll do it line item by line item.

» so first of all we'll get it on the table can we have a motion to approve these goals and objectives mr chairman i make a motion that we approve our goals and objectives for 2019 2020 very good a second second second for mrs snodgrass yes david thank you very much all right mr tucker you want to open it for a discussion yes sir i just want to start off by saying thank you to Santee, Lynch's, and Cal for coming up and spending the day and helping us dig through this. And it just didn't happen that day, but the preparation prior to trying to get our thoughts to you so you can formulate this. So I say thanks and appreciate your hard work from Kershaw County.

» I just want to say also that the retreat I thought was very well, and I'll have some more comments in my council briefing in reference to um what i thought as far as um for next year that i think we can do a little different or um a little better but um i'm acceptable to these goals um that we've set and uh projects and i look forward to voting on this mr jones thank you mr chairman i'll go ahead and get mine out of the way because go ahead it makes a whole lot of sense um let me first say that i regret my early departure right before the goal setting portion of the retreat i had to leave early due to a family illness however after reading the priorities i'm probably glad that i wasn't there i feel the kershaw county council i need you to make a motion now oh i'm sorry or do you want to go

» ahead and give a speech uh i'll be glad to start over yeah we want to go through them so we can uh yeah and i have an amendment i'm going to make okay i'll stand by But you let Mr. Tucker speak without a motion. Why won't you let me speak without a motion? Because you indicated you were going to make some changes. But if you're not going to make the changes now. Well, I was going to speak, and then I was going to make it on the table when we get it on the table. Please go ahead. But I don't mind if you want to go ahead and get a motion on the floor in a second. That would be terrific. Yeah, so we can see where you're headed. Yeah, if you would. I'm not making the motion. Okay, good. All right. Is anybody making a motion? We've got a motion in a second. It's on the table.

» Yeah, it's on the table. We're going through each goal to see which you want to change. Okay, then, if we have a motion and a second, and you let Mr. Tucker speak, why is there an issue? Well, I thought, I'm sorry I didn't mean to interrupt you, but I thought you started out by saying you were going to make an amendment. I said I was going to make some comments. Okay, please, go ahead. And then I may make an amendment after my comments. Please, go ahead. This is as confusing as a container law. But anyway, all right, thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm going to start over. Listen, folks, I feel that Kershaw County Council goals for the fiscal year 2019 and 2020 are overly ambitious, overwhelming, and non-realistic.

» Council has listed 12 items as high priority, 14 items as minimum priority, and 11 items as low priority. However, what disturbs me the most is what is in the high priority list. After everything I have said and brought to council's attention about economic development over the past six months, and the loss of 604 jobs, and a loss of $89 million in investments, and after asking that we get with the county administrator to set realistic goals for him to achieve in 2019-2020 in industrial jobs and investments, then I look at our high priority list. It's on the board right behind us and right behind you, which has 12 bullet points. And I see the first thing is to form a task force to improve White Pond Road, Whiting Way, and I-20. And there's nothing wrong with this.

» However, that is a state DOT project. But for that to be our number one thing, I'm lost. The second item is develop recreational splash pads starting in the city through a partnership with the city of Camden. One, how is that more important than industrial jobs and industrial recruiting when we haven't had but 25 industrial jobs over the last seven years and maybe about $5 million in investments? Two, why didn't we use the same concept when we bought the swamp land, excuse me, the river park, at the river park in Lugov? Why didn't we partner with the city of Camden over their river park? They're doing the same thing that we're doing. They're going to be spending millions of dollars. They're going to have identical pretty much trails and piers and whatever, houses or community centers.

» But I just don't understand why we couldn't have worked together on that. And that would have been a huge success for us if we could have. One, they're not building in a floodplain, I don't believe. And then I see other items such as identifying initiatives to publicly display and leverage the county's military and veterans' friendliness. I'm a veteran. I think we need to act on the county fire service plan. I think we need to do that and we need to put that in some of the top priorities. But let me just move on and I'll move very quickly finish here. There's another bullet point up there that says and continue the county vehicle replacement program. Folks, that's an administrative issue. We've been doing that for eight years.

» Why is that a top priority on the goals for 2019-20? Folks, once again, we are not focusing on industry, jobs, and investment, which we need to and which should be our first priority. I will not support the draft of the Kershaw County Council Goals for fiscal year 2019-2020. What I propose is that we only have three high priorities that are realistic, five medium priorities, and seven low priorities. I would start by putting economic development as a number one high priority and fire service as a number two and SROs as a number three. By focusing on three critical areas, we can focus our county's efforts and accomplishments. And I think these are important tasks in bringing good jobs to our citizens and protecting their property and the students of Kershaw County, which are our future.

» Only then should we focus on other issues after we accomplish those. So having said that, Mr. Chairman, I will go ahead and make the motion that we only have three high priorities, five medium priorities, and seven low priorities. And the three priorities that are high will be realistic in my view. And I will start by putting economic development as number one, high priority, the fire service as number two, and the SROs as number three. That would be my amendment. All right. We have an amendment. We have a second. There is no second. the motion dies we move to another mr. chairman thank you for your time and thank you thank you mr.

» Tucker do you have an amendment I do have a clarification can I just ask for yes sir I think when this came to us from Kyle Kelly if you look on page two items for future discussion I think we need a little explanation of why that's that way if I think we need a little explanation as to the formatting here because it seems to me this ought to be rolled into low priority mr kelly you created a little issue here for us can you come up and explain the last two bullets no it's not no thanks you blew it out all right we'll see uh danny's will do his magic thank you you take mine not to hold up uh i would explain that to us go ahead please whereas the low priority items received at least one indication from a council member that they were a priority uh i would suggest they someone put them up the

» re we just ran out of dots and if it's a low priority we could just roll these in together if somebody wants to make that amendment later on in the discussion but i did want to point that out to you mr tucker i interrupted you go ahead well while mr cal's up there um it is it is my understanding when we were going through this, and it just hadn't started this year since you've been facilitating, and even when USC did it, these are not in any type of priority order in their categories. Am I correct by saying that? They are, the order you see is the order of those individual preferences.

» So while they're categorized in a way that those breaks are, the breaks between the three categories are natural breaks right in those in those numerical order but within those priorities they're it's like splitting hairs to to to rate them one over another yeah so i mean you just put them on a piece of paper and um we go at them they're all high priorities and we can start from the bottom or the middle or do like a bag of popcorn just shake it up and pull out of it yeah certainly okay now my my other point last year right yeah that's that's the system we've used now to mr Jones point here with um not approving this how many uh of those goals and objectives are yours Mr.

» Jones because you didn't turn your sheet in you're exactly right I had to leave early no no this was prior to the meeting exactly and that's why I brought them tonight and I took your your list that y'all presented and was handed out to everybody the ones that y'all did yes sir you guys the county council I took that information and I went and went through it and I made my priorities which i have the right to do oh i'm not doubting that but everything i did here tonight is correct and right if you put yours up on that board where mr cow can have it where we can put the dots then we'll have a chance to prioritize yours into this list as well but that wasn't turned in so the process this is strictly mr jones yeah thank you mr um chairman councilman tucker what you're saying makes no sense wha

» tsoever you understand exactly what i'm saying i took the goals that this county council put up here because i had to leave due to a family illness i took the goals that you guys put up here because there are some good things such as economic development fire service sros i just don't think sros should be in the the medium range i don't think fire service should be low i don't think that economic development should be low i think they should be the top three and i think when you have as many as we have up there it becomes mind-boggling and And so I made my amendment, and I recognize the three priorities that I have. Okay. Well, I'm going to move on also, Mr. Chairman.

» I just want to make the point that we do this because our budget dictates what the administrator can and will be able to do. You can have all the pipe dreams and the things that you want, but if we don't fund it from up here, it won't get done. He does not have a checkbook that he can write personal checks out to run this county. So something as simple as vehicle, vehicles. Yeah, it sounds simple, but if we don't fund it from up here, there's no way he can make it happen. So that's why we do this. And your goals and objectives follow your funding, which helps us to make sure that we get our budget right for 2019, 2020. Let me ask, make a couple of points here, Mr. Jones, and I'll get to you. All right, thank you. During the period when Mr.

» Jones was absent, which was in the morning, the city of Camden strongly suggested that we pursue the water park and strongly recognized the collateral benefit of having their park and the park that we have on the West Bank at US 1. In fact, he said they entertain two different purposes. So there's a whole, and maybe we can take some time to back brief you, Mr. Jones, on what you missed by not being there in the morning. And then secondly, Mary, did you get priorities from all council members? And if so, who did you not get one? Okay, so the first time we're seeing it is tonight. Mr. Jones, I'm concerned that your priorities are not being received in time for this body to operate on in the time that we all agreed that we would operate on them.

» I see that your three priorities are in here, And we want to make sure the 10,000 people that you represent, voices are heard even though you weren't there to express it. So how do you propose that we put those down? Well, let me make some clarification on some of your comments and Mr. Tucker's comments, which I found interesting. One, you say that, Mr. Tucker, that we have to put the rotation of vehicles on the retreat list or the wish list because we're going to put it in the budget. we don't put every single budget item on our priority list for our retreat. That's an administrative issue, and I stand by that. And, Mr.

» Chairman, when you talked about the city of Camden Water Park, you know, that they came to us, why didn't we go to them when we started developing the river park for all this amount of money that we were going to put into it? Because we're doing the same thing, exactly duplicate of what they're doing pretty much. Step by step, we're just we're putting the same thing in over in a flood zone. And, you know, when you talk about me not being there while I was there, I had a I had a one of my children at home was sick and I was late getting there because my wife had to go into work. And I don't mind telling the public that. And I also left early because he was still there by himself. So I left. But I tried to make an effort to get there. And I spent a couple of hours there.

» And I went to Miss Mary and I asked her to give me a list of the priorities. and she did and i got them and i accepted y'all's list and i actually am working off your priorities mr chairman i'm working off your priorities mr tucker for y'all to sit there and to absolutely try to dismiss what i've done or what i'm trying to present here tonight is just unfortunate because wait i'm not finished go ahead because bottom line everything that i mentioned in my report tonight and in my list of priorities are right up here on this board there's no difference so they weren't blindsided i'm just i have different priorities than they do i happen to think that if we need two ambulances and we're going to take four hundred thousand dollars and put it into the river park on the shelf for the future needs

» that we should buy those two ambulances first that's where we differ that's where we i'm not finished i see you getting ready to say something that's where we differ when i see a list of priorities and i see green space green space green space, green space. And I have sat here for six months and I have identified two phony companies on our webpage, private, confidential companies that totaled 200 jobs and $10 million worth of investment that did not exist. I did not get one single, and I don't want to thank you from my colleagues up here, but when I did not get a single acknowledgement for recognizing this being done, it was as if it didn't matter.

» And then they want to sit up here tonight and try to discredit me because I had a sick child at home and I only got to spend a few hours at the retreat. Unbelievable. But I'm going to tell you something. He talked about the 10,000 people I represent, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman, I represent 63,000 or whatever people in this county. I don't represent just my district. I've been doing it going on 13 years. Whether you're in my district or not, if you call me, I'm there. I work for you. I don't work for politicians and bureaucrats. And they're attacking me tonight. And that's okay. I can handle it. That's what people elected me forward to stand up and be a voice. And I will be a voice for what I think is right. I don't think they did anything wrong. I just don't agree with them.

» But because I don't agree with them, they want to try to personally discredit me and tear me down. Well, I'm not here to do that to them. I just don't agree with their priorities. I don't believe, I just don't, and I don't mean to laugh. You can't make this up. To me, it's just that ridiculous. But anyway, I'm not finished. But I'm going to tell you something. Everything that I said in my report, I just said I would start with putting economic development priorities first. Why are we so upset about that? And then I said I would put the fire service second. Because we made a commitment to the people in Kershaw County that we were going to complete something. And let me tell you about that promise we made to the people in Kershaw County, the commitment.

» And this could be twisted and spun any way they want to spin it. But we made a commitment that we were going to do a referendum question. We were going to study the fire service. We're going to do some questions and put it on a referendum for the people to tell us what they thought. Get some feedback from the folks. And then SROs. Boy, that I won't go into all of it. That is a nightmare. We on this council screwed that up. We told them we messed that up. We were funding SROs for 12 whatever years. Then all of a sudden we figured out, well, hey, if we can dump the SROs on the school district, switch them over to them, free up our $750,000, and we got money. We can put that somewhere else and have the school district create a new millage or find the funding to do the SROs.

» And they can giggle, smirk, laugh at what I'm saying, but they know I'm saying the truth. They know I'm speaking the truth. And I will stand up for what I think is right. But to personally attack me for not being there this weekend when I was there, I think it's just very unfortunate. But those are my three focuses, and the three things that I focused on came from your list. All right. Mr. Chairman, thank you. Okay, we'll move on. Back to the rules of the House, we agreed it was a line item changes. I want to first say that I would like to agree with the Councilman, but he is making false statements. That is just, it just goes beyond the time available to address those points. We return to the discipline of this House and to see if there are further amendments on a line item basis.

» I suggested that we take the last two, and I would ask if there would be an amendment that would take the last items for future discussion and roll those into the low priority. Is there such an amendment or a motion? Okay. Okay. They stay there. Now, any other items for a motion? Mr. Connell. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have one under low priority. Forgive my count. This is one, two, three down.

» we've got developed strategic plan for u.s one corridor elgin to lugoff uh given that is the most densely populated area in the county and the fastest growing and uh and i think the one regarding east camden is in the right place i'd suggest that we move it to at least a medium priority to account for the residential and hopefully economic development growth that will happen in that area yeah just as a as an example of let's make the motion oh sure i'll make the motion. Which one is it, please? So that is the motion. The third bullet point down, develop strategic plan for U.S. 1 corridor. Yeah, my motion is we move it up to medium priority. Okay, can we have a second? Second. Second from that's you, David? Can't hear you. Yes. Yeah, thank you. Second.

» Any discussion? Go ahead, Ben, please. Sure. With everything we have going on at the White Pond Road 20 exit, you're aware of the asphalt plant, Earnest Health, making a move there. Love Chevrolet coming in and the additional residential growth. I think the entire White Pond Road, Highway one corridor is important for us to try to get ahead of and yes some of those are d.o.t projects and funds but we through the cmcog worked on commissioning the westwater e-transportation study and if we don't speak up none of these projects will ever happen i've seen the queue of d.o.t funded projects and we are way down the list and the only way you can get ahead of another project is if you can show matching funds or an exigent or emergency circumstance and i'm not quite saying we we have an emergency ye

» t, but you better believe that White Pond Road and 20, additional economic development is going to come. I think paying attention to infrastructure in that area is actually an economic development move, because it won't be too long before a hotel or something like that comes, maybe another restaurant or two. So, you know, I'd appreciate your consideration there. Other discussion? Mr. Tucker, please, sir. Yes, sir. Mr.

» Connell, as much as I would love to support your amendment um and move it up to a higher priority which i think it needs to go um i believe in the process that we took and what cal came up with from our votes we had that opportunity to speak to that with our dots and we didn't so i'm gonna not support this tonight and support the process that we did because what i don't want to get in the habit of doing is rearranging what our priorities are during the retreat after the fact yeah let me ask a question in deference to both of you uh the the first item under the high priorities is the task force on white pond road and whiting way uh it's not because it's first it's not top priority but it's in the high priority column ben is that inside your construct of how you made that motion i mean that t

» hat's part of how i view it i view that as a very high priority and i would say uh going from Elgin to Lugov is right up there with it, but I'd be satisfied if we placed it at a medium priority. Listen, I know a matter -- a lot of this is just a matter of degree, but I think there's precedence, Mr. Tucker, for adjusting these goals. I remember, I think we had one or two votes last year where if a goal didn't seem realistic, we moved it or adjusted it. And, you know, I'm just shooting from the hip. I can't remember the exact point. Mr. I'm going to say I don't remember that. Mr. Well, you know, I'm pretty new at it, so a lot of it seems fresh to me. And I recall doing that and thinking, oh, okay, we can adjust our goals, which I think is a healthy thing. Yes, sir.

» But I also believe this is part of the process tonight. So if you're persuaded by the positions and arguments I've made, you know, so be it. I hope it works. But if not, you know, we'll continue pushing. But I know this much. Yes, sir. If we don't focus on these road projects, even if they're state-funded, they will never happen. And you're absolutely right. And that doesn't say that we can't reach down from high to low to medium as, you know, time or opportunity dictates. Because we've done that before. We just haven't moved them off the list and shuffled them around. Mr. Chairman, if I might. Please respond. Just last point is I've found in my short times serving in government that a lot of times opportunity is made by the power of your will.

» So if you can almost will something to happen and show someone that's important and gather some matching funds and demonstrate the data that supports it, you can actually get something done. So with that, that's all I have to share, Mr. Chairman. Let me just go back to infrastructure for a minute. We've already addressed the sewer issues out there, and I'm really happy with the way that's developing. But if you go to this West Water Retransportation Study that you, Ben, I, and others, and Mayor Emmons slaved over, much of that is in the high priority as expressed to that other cog, the CM cog in Richland, that controls transportation money. It would not be inconsistent. To move it from a low to a high priority or a low to a medium priority is a motion that's before the table right now.

» Other discussion? Yeah, Mr. Bozart. I'm sorry. Mr. Carnell, on the other end of that road that we're discussing here going out the other way through Palmetto Asphalt and so forth, going out to White Ponds Road, we've got notice that maybe there might be a truck stop going out there. Would you like to amend your motion to include that also? No, I think that's already addressed in what we discussed. That's White Palm Road adjacent to Whiting Way and Highway 20. What we're talking about right now is Highway 1 from Elgin to Lugoff. Oh, yes, Elgin. Okay. Yeah, okay. Yeah, David, go ahead. Yeah, I was just going to say that I'll support this move just kind of in good faith, not that I'm – because I do feel like that whole Highway 1 corridor needs to be a focus.

» However, I do want to point out that I specifically asked for the East Camden part of the corridor because Elgin gets natural attention because you're so close to the Columbia sprawl that it just gets natural attention. I'm hoping that what can remain a medium and a high priority goal is Highway 1 in East Camden because it is one of the most densely populated, unincorporated areas of our county. And I believe that it has gone under such neglect over the last few years that I believe as we give attention to it, that it too has a lot of potential to have a lot of development.

» So I'm definitely with you of kind of moving your side up to kind of be even, but at the same time, just want to make it clear that that was my goal to put in there to make sure that East Camden finally got its fair shake and kind of a fair deal at the county table. and excited about that i'll share more of that probably in my in my remarks but i have another uh motion that i'll make and i'm assuming we'll need to get past this one as far as moving a priority ready to call the question all right let's move to a vote on this amendment all those in favor of the amendment to move item number three on the elgin us1 blue golf corridor to medium priorities signify by raising your hand uh it's mr snigrass mr gardner mr burns mr bozard mr jones mr connell all those opposed as mr tucker and it passe

» s other amendments you said you had one yeah i would uh would it be out of order to entertain a motion uh mr jones i mean you're yours and not my delivery system is not exactly the same um but you did say something that that what's your motion and then we'll talk about it okay i'll make a motion we move sro to high priority okay second and we have a second for mr jones uh discussion from you sir yeah just honestly that was kind of oversight on my on my part i just uh when i when we do these goals i just i didn't take them just in one particular order for for me this was just a way for county to kind of get these on the board and it's not that the first one is the most important the last one is the last important it was just hey let's get this on the board so so staff can know what we're thi

» nking about from a policy standpoint on how to begin to create uh to create the budget so I didn't mean to miss the SRO. I mean, we definitely know that's important and looking forward to having a discussion on that. So that would be my motion. Other discussion? I would like to. Yeah, go ahead, Jimmy. Councilman Snodgrass, let me just tell you, thank you very much. You're a good man, and I know that. Politics is a different world, but bottom line is you're a tough guy. But thank you so much for recognizing that and making that motion, and I was honored. I just didn't want the other stuff to go away. Let Mr. Jones finish, please. Mr. Snodgrass? Apologize. Go ahead, Mr. Jones. You don't need to apologize to me. There's nothing wrong with us having a little bit of conversation up here.

» Go ahead, Mr. Jones. Mr. Chairman, relax. No, go ahead. Just relax. Mr. Jones, go right ahead. Just relax, please, sir. Go right ahead. You relax. Go right ahead. You relax. You know I'm still going to go ahead. All right. But anyway, thank you so much, Councilman Snodgrass, for that motion. I appreciate it. Other discussions? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, sir. Mr. Tucker. For the same reasons, Mr. Snodgrass, I stated to Councilman Cornell, I won't be standing my same position. Yeah, Ben, please go ahead. I'd support it to the extent it means we want to emphasize to the state government that they should make true on their promise of having an SRO in every school and funding it. To the extent these goals mean we match them up with funding, you know, I don't know.

» I just remember the state, the governor's race saying that he was going to fund SROs in every school, and I hope it wasn't just political speech, but that they actually make true on that promise. I didn't see it in the, I'll comment on that. it's not in the house budget uh i have not seen it submitted by the governor so it so far not in substance in any one of the the finance committees in the house or the senate okay again but um there has been a discussion as we shared before and but let me just back up again and maybe i should have said this up front mr tucker knows the deal and that is we're not here today to do the finance part of this we have now months of budget meetings that include one an aggressive economic development plan two sros and on and on and on so uh just like at the stat

» e house uh it doesn't mean anything until we put money against it which is the next step but it's important to know where you're going before you go there so that was a whole deal about doing goals and objectives uh who wanted to say chairman if i may yeah mr jones what you just said i totally agree with the last part of it thank you others well i just you know just to be just to we're all clear that this is just a for us to uh to work with the school district because we all know because act 388 this is really or i mean we don't dump it on the school board that's i mean obviously that's that's their expense but i i am open to making a priority to work with them to make it you know ready to call the question here? All right.

» We have a motion to move the SRO officer and school safety plan from a medium to a high priority. All those in favor, signify by raising your hand. And it's Mr. Jones, Connell, Mr. Bozard, Burns, and Mr. Snodgrass opposed. Mr. Gardner and Mr. Tucker, for reasons already stated. Okay, it passes. But we have two amendments, and let me just make sure I got them. Could you restate those two amendments strategic plan for us one corridor? And the second one I mean that goes to a medium and the second one is SROs to high other amendments There are none if I could mr.

» Chairman I'd like to make an amendment that we take an aggressive economic development plan We are setting goals for the administrator for the next year coming up that we put that as a number one item We set, so I'm going to restate that and make sure I got it right. Set plans for the, no, goals for the administrator as a part of the economic plan. Correct. Do we have a second? Second. Not a grass second to it. Mr. Jones, you want to lead discussion? I think it speaks for itself. Other discussions? Excuse me, excuse me, Mr. Chairman. Go right ahead. We've had our heads buried in the sand for the last seven plus years, And I think that it's only reasonable that we set some guidelines and goals that we'd like to see achieved in the year coming up. I think it would be fair to the public.

» I think they deserve that as well because we've had no success. And when you talk about when we sit here and talk about my numbers or my comments not being correct, that was said by members of these county council of this county council when I was giving those reports. But then the next day they came off the Web page. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Another discussion. Mr. Snodgrass, you seem to be on board. I think goals and objectives are always good, as long as they're realistic. My second was not to say that I'll agree with every goal that Mr. Jones will put out, but it seemed like a... Okay, Mr. Snodgrass. Mr. Jones, go ahead. First off, I have said that from the very beginning that they should always be realistic.

» And second off, I don't think you have to justify why you support me on an issue. Thank you. Mr. Gardner. I think it's already in the high priority. says develop a more aggressive economic development marketing program it's already in our priority i don't know that we need to reinvent this this is tucker go ahead i want more clarity i mean this is kind of broad and vague so um give some clarity okay please i would you talk about broad and vague tell me about everything you've got written up there everything up there is vague i mean there's nothing really specific and and when we talk about setting the goals i mean we sit down and we talk We have a work session with the county administrator.

» We sit down and we tabulate some goals and things that we'd like to see them achieve this coming year in economic development to maybe give some direction to try to have some success. Because for whatever reason, we're just not able to close the deal. We've got a $2 million building sitting up there. We've got a lot of work that we've done. We've got a $17.2 million bond that's going to cost us $31 million over 30 years of time. So we've invested money. We paid an expert to come here, and we paid her $5,000, and she spoke for an hour and told us that we were great, but yet she never answered my questions when I was there. And why is it so complicated to understand that we, the administrator is our employee. The other employees don't work for us.

» Why is it so complicated? Something as simple as just set some goals for him. He cannot develop when you haven't had any success. So I don't understand why we're making this so complicated. And you know as well as I know, Councilman Tucker, Vice Chairman Tucker, you know what you're doing. You know exactly what you're asking me. And you know that all we've got to do is sit down in a work session, come up with some goals for the administrator and economic development and move forward. And I'm talking about realistic goals within the next year. Look at how much we've lost. Look at how much we have taken off our website that we had up there, 604, 89.9 million. And I was told those numbers were wrong. The same thing. Mr. Jones has got his numbers wrong. I don't agree with his figures.

» We have created 500 jobs where they're gone. They were never filled. Mr. Tucker, go ahead. Thank you, sir. You're welcome. Well, I think you made my point exactly. These goals and objectives up here has been discussed and there's been a lot of dialogue. So that's why I'm wanting, if you want to do this, you're right. You put dots on a board. Hold on, time, time, time. Hang on, Mr. Jones.

» with three hours ago yeah um there was seriously time spent and dialogue and our good healthy hours down there and staff going over these objectives and goals and if you want something for the administrator we can work on it in the work sessions i don't have a problem having that conversation and that dialogue but to put this on this list from the retreat i think it's inappropriate and not and and not where it goes because if that was then we should have listed once again and in in the request we got from santee lynch's and then it would have been on the bulletin uh on those boards so we could prioritize them and i say that because you know we're going away from the process and i'm not into going away from the process we went through this this is what we said we're going to do now wherever

» we um vary a little bit within but to add stuff and move stuff i'm not i'm not on board tonight mr chairman uh let's see anybody else mr jones go first i don't think we're adding i think we're just we're just having a discussion and we're getting to the nuts and bolts of what we'd like to see out of some of the things that are captioned up here um i do want to say one thing to you personally mr tucker directly look me straight in the eye my friend you are very consistent you're very passionate about what you believe. I just don't believe in the same things you do. However, I do respect you. You've always been very polite and I appreciate that as well. Okay. Any other discussion? Mr. Bozard. Thank you. I want to ask Mr. Carpenter a question.

» We're discussing this development countywide community economic development plan with a focus on commercial and real estate initiatives. Is that correct? That was one of the items. Yes, sir. You explain that to me, please. Well, you mean talking about the executive session no right here high priority where are you on number uh it's like number and a half priority okay what what that was mr bozard was we had discussed putting some focus in the county's efforts on attracting retail and commercial growth six percent growth thank you that term now i have another question what is the function of the economic development office industrial growth sir industrial growth okay uh wait a minute now hold on okay well go ahead i'm trying to figure out mr chairman how we gonna get him that's what i'm tryi

» ng to figure out okay how we how we're going to do this we're going to get another committee or what we're going to do put extra work on the economic let me let me impose there uh as i said at the retreat we're going to have an executive session on part of that tonight oh i'm sorry i'll hush thank you no but but then there's a second issue is we have a work session during the budget session to get at the particulars of that plan going forward but i was just confused whether we were going to put another committee together to do this or we're going to do it during the budget cycle okay thank you sir yeah okay i'm ready to call the question but let me first say that is absolutely false that we've lost jobs we're at full employment in this county uh you got for our higher signs everywhere we've

» had increase in our net net on the philo funding line of several million dollars so i want the people out here in this group and on this board to know that i challenge the repeated discussion of taking an isolated point and saying the economic development has not grown it is demonstrably wrong now with that we move to a vote all of those in favor of the amendment to the goals and objectives to specify goals and objectives for economic development for the administrator signify by raising your hand we have mr snodgrass and mr jones all those opposed signify and it's mr connell mr burns mr bozard mr gardner mr tucker and the motion fails uh other motions are we ready to move on to the final vote we have three and two amendments uh strategic uh the let me see if i got this right um the strategy

» uh the one mr connell's amendment to develop to move the uh us-1 elgin lugoff corridor to medium priority has passed in the first motion and uh the second we'll be voting on is moving sros to high priority all in favor of the goals and objectives as amended signify by raising your hand and we have mr connell mr bozard mr burns i don't think we got a motion in a second did we we got it oh yeah we got to back up oh yeah all those in favor of those of uh i need that no no no i make a motion that we adopt the amendments to our goals and objectives as stated. Thank you. Second. Second from Mr. Connell. Discussion? There is none. Move to a vote. All those in favor, signify by raising your hand. Mrs. Snodgrass, Mr. Tucker. Thank you, Sammy. You're welcome. Mr. Gardner, Mr. Burns, Mr.

» Bozard, and Mr. Connell. All those opposed? Mr. Jones, and the motion passes, and the goals and objectives are passed as written and as amended. We move now to item number three, Heritage Point 2 Landscape and Irrigation Bid. It's at tab I. And on the board, Mr. Carpenter, please. Mr. Chairman, members of council, we have in front of you a low bid being requested for approval tonight by council for the landscaping and irrigation of the Heritage Point 2 spec building. A low bid of smoke irrigation for $41,225. Very good. Can we have a motion to approve? Make a motion to approve the said bid for the lowest bidder. Mr. Tucker, a second? Second. Second. Mr. Bozard, any discussion? Yeah, go ahead. Mr.

» Carpenter, how many square feet are we talking about here? That's 25,000 square feet of sod and a comparable amount of grass seed. Irrigation system? Okay. Okay, thank you. Full up our irrigation. Okay, very good question. Comments? Quick comment. Yeah, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of county council. What is our total that we have spent so far on the industrial sites? If I don't have it with me at the moment, I can get it for you, Mr. Jones. This money's coming out of the bond? Yes, sir. As I said, this money's coming out of the bond. How about this? Where are we at with the bond? Is it $5 million, $6 million? No, sir. We're much closer to $4 million. $4 million. Yes, sir. With this? Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you. Others? Okay. We're ready to move to a vote.

» all those in favor signify by raising your hand and it's unanimous Mary move to item number four proposal for 2019 countywide aerial ortho Express imagery service tab Jay this sounds like what I used to do in Bosnia mr. mr. Carpenter can you explain this please mr. chair members counsel the last time we did overflight of the county was in 2015 we are looking to do a new aerial overfly of the county the reassessment starts this coming year so we need to get up-to-date aerials on the books you have to do those in winter in order to get the best overflight because an adjacent county is also doing one we can get a discount if you go with them so we're requesting that we go ahead and do the overflight now and then we can pay it out of the next two budgets all right do we have a motion to approve

» i'll make the motion that we approve the aerial photography all right sammy uh second second second from mr bozard any discussion yes yeah sammy go right um mr carpenter what you think an estimate cost is going to be on this that's going to be forty six thousand dollars total okay so that um thirty five hundred is not i'm sorry that thirty five hundred on there is not going to be included no sir that's the state will pay pay that thirty five hundred for the three band infrared that they'll be getting okay thank you we don't use that ourself okay say again the price, please? $46,000. Yeah. Other discussion, Mr. Gardner? Who else uses this information? Just the county? No, it's our GIS. The GIS uses it. City, county, the state, realtors.

» Do we charge those folks to use this information since we're putting the bill for it? It depends on how they request it from us. If they go online, we don't. So anybody uses it online, it's available for everybody. If they request actual data from the county, then there's a cost for it. I think a number of years ago it was $90,000. It was.

» and i know the city uses a lot of that for their sewer and those sorts of things is this not something that we could partner with them to get them to pay for part of this um for the city itself my knowledge we haven't it's the whole county you can't you can't not take the city i'm taking the county so we can turn the request they do it but if we do it we have to for all of the county oh i understand i'm just looking for ways to save some money yes sir since since since there are other entities that use it i know several years ago that the chamber used this as well and sold maps off of it for profit and uh i requested that they make a contribution towards it they didn't like that very much but uh but still you know we foot the bill for it and i don't know why we couldn't ask for at least a s

» mall portion like i said depending on on how they requested data from us understand that we got charged no problem very good others all right no further discussion let's move to a vote all those in favor signify by raising your hand and it's unanimous and it's pretty clever there mr carpenter thank you it passes we move to council briefings and it begins with you ben please oh just two things of course i'm i'm a little biased towards wrestling is a local high school sport but i wanted to congratulate lugolf elgin high school for winning their region. Long tradition of stout wrestling performance there. And then North Central's athletic program, their coaches and assistant coach, Coach Brazel, and also Coach Jeremy should be commended. They finished second in the state as a team.

» The team competition happens right before you have individuals coming up in the next few weeks, but it's the best they've ever performed in the state. It's a real credit to the program, the parents, and the school district in supporting that program who are just forming young men through trials that will prepare them for the rest of their lives once you've been out there in spandex under in the light for an extended period of uh your athletic career not much else can bother you that's all i have mr thank you mr jones mr chairman i have no report tonight all right very good mr snigrass i just wanted to uh thank the staff for doing a great job of organizing a wonderful retreat for us yep it was the first one that i was able to be a part of and i think those are important as organizations i've

» been a part of before it's it's always good to uh to get your goals out there so you can know where you're going and so i appreciate that appreciate council you're helping me out getting some some things that have been important to me uh on on on the radar a lot of folks in east camden have just made several comments to me that for the first time in a long time they've they've just heard those two words mentioned together in paper and other goals and objectives, and that's East Camden. So thank you so much. In fact, I told my council members at the retreat, I said, my goal in these next four years is for you to get tired of me saying East Camden. So I really appreciate that. And I do want to just say to Vic and his staff, you guys do a great job.

» I know we just kind of got finished with a lively discussion about some things, but just want to reiterate that I believe you do a great job. And I know that economic development is a tricky thing. There are successes that we'll never see just because of the nature of what economic development is. But just wanted to just to reiterate that. Just keep on keeping on. Mr. Tucker. Thank you.

» Just want to dovetail a little bit on what Councilman Snodgrass said and give you a little bit of my feedback from the retreat uh awesome job from staff miss mary and danny and vick um i thought in my personal opinion that some of our department heads got slighted and what do i mean by that it was a long day saturday it was real long um didn't mind staying but um our administrator had to amend the schedule just so we could stay in the time frame that we stayed in so i'm recommending all of you unless you know god sees different we'll be here next year that we maybe talk about a two-day retreat where we start that friday early afternoon and then go into saturday so because it's important to hear from our department heads and our elected officials um and it's not just what they're requesting

» but what they have accomplished over this past budget year and where they're at so um that's my seed that i'm sowing tonight and we'll be bringing that back up as we get out of this budget year coming up into the new year and i hope that you would consider that the other thing that i like to say that i'm i've had conversation with the administrator and also our economic development director miss peggy i'm going to be looking to see if we can maybe reboot our economic development committee so i'll be getting some feedback and input from all of you and we're going to see can we get that maybe restructured in a very positive way and her problem was we didn't show up for meetings i'm just going to put it out there the people that were sitting on that board didn't show up and she felt that she w

» asn't being productive with that group so it she didn't dissolve it it dissolved itself so um keep that in mind that i will be bringing that up and proposing that to my colleagues That concludes my report. Mr. Gardner? Briefly, Ben kind of stole my thunder on the North Central question team. That's okay. That's okay. I'd like to thank Chris for his report on how important that EMS station that we built on the north end of the county is. That's a testament. And I thank my colleagues for, you know, putting that there. We have another one going up in Lugoff now that is vital to the services of our people in our county.

» but uh but thank thank you chris for showing us how important that is to those people in that now thank you sir since our last retreat i have been going through the 208 pages on the survey that the excuse me planning zoning had i'm on page 60 right now there is some very good comments that the citizens of kershaw county uh gave us at the same time there were some very hurtful and meaningful comments also however we ask for it so we got to live with the good and the bad so we welcome the comments whether they're good or bad so don't don't be afraid of what i just said there some of the um comments and mr uh carper and i talked just a little bit ago before the meeting started about this we seem to have a problem in our county with some signs some not allowing big enough and some of them and i

» come to find out that the uh ordinance from mr michael i mean connelly has changed a couple years back that we are using and can use bigger signs now out on the interstate and so forth so that's one issue that's been taken care of but the biggest thing throughout that survey that i found so far on my 60 pages is that we aren't keeping the people informed the people really don't know what's going on in the county and they talk about transportation studies out on 601 and then Elgin we had two of them one of them is partially funded and one of them is not no money is in the other one yet so that's that's one thing and the redoing what mr.

» in talked about earlier us one that was one of the studies we done that's one no money for yet if uh do we have that on the internet mr connelly is that available to the people these questions i mean these surveys i would suggest that y'all want to get some good education read it but uh they talk about new zoning to protect eyesores they talk about removal of junk trash and so forth out people's yards you know we can only do so much uh we talk about ordinance trying to uh eliminate a lot of trash we're dealing with people that own land they talk about lights off the interstate coming in off of us uh 90 exit 98 92 and need lights out there they talk about why don't we have some clean community um committee we do have one we need to put out the information who this committee is mr carpenter s

» o if anybody's got these issues they can come or read it someplace and let them know that we do have a beautification committee it's called a clean community is what name of it is there's a lot of things here and i said we're not keeping the people informed and maybe we're dropping our ball on that maybe we need to do a better job in keeping the people conformed they talk about build industrial parks apparently the people don't know that we've got how many parks five is it five three okay i'm sorry three industrial parks already and again mr carpenter that's what i'm talking about maybe we have not been doing our job in informing keeping the people informed it's a lot um one fellow said in there economic development is not a function of government i'm in the process right now of reading a D

» emocracy Unfolded book written by some educated people here in South Carolina, by all South Carolinians, that said the same thing. Said the government needs to get out of the Economic Development Office. Now, whether that's so or not, I'm going to let somebody smarter than me talk about that. But this is comments that you, the citizens of Kershaw County, is in that survey. Like I said, again, if you want to see some good reading, go read it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you very much. And I'll close it out, and then we'll hear from the administrator and the attorney. Yeah, high school sports, it's the best thing in the world. Terrific. We've watched basketball and wrestling. And we're now into the spring ball, both for high school.

» And I would encourage everybody also, if you've got children, to sign up for the rec department. I think it's been extended until, I think, another week or so. but that's for spring ball conducted by the rec department. I direct your attention back to the minutes we just approved in which it was stated by D.D. Caldwell that we're on the right track in economic development and if anything, we need to be more aggressive and that is what we're about. And that begins with an executive session we're soon to have and also the budget sessions to follow. and you've seen the passion that's associated with providing the resources we need so we can provide the services that our children and our families need. We're all about that. Nobody's against it. It's just how to get there.

» I would also ask you to look at what Kyle Kelly and Mike Conley have done with Vision 2030. This thing is standing the test of time. We're into our third year with this. It's not even three years old yet. it won all america county it won national level recognition and we promise the citizens that every year we take a hard look at how we're doing measure progress from the previous year and then write the goals and objectives that you just heard us within with passion i would say argue about and now this turns into the next step which is the budget process doesn't mean anything if there's no money placed against it so we now move into the budget process boy you want to see some fun come to that and then we'll come in here and do three readings and a public hearing and we come out the other en

» d and it'll be really interesting um i'm really looking forward to it but this is a part of our contract with the county every city in this county voted on it in favor the chamber of commerce did the school district did and a number of other civic organizations voted in favor of this. And we just did the test of time, and I congratulate Mike and Kyle and all members of the core team, past, present, and future, who helped us get that done. Lastly, it pains me a little bit in the chairman to have to say this, but process shouldn't drive out product. And we want to hear from everybody. And as chairman, I've been also asked to be mindful of the time that some of these men up here have. Some of us are businessmen and some of us lead these proceedings and proceed all over the world tonight.

» And I am mindful that we have to produce the best product for our county and let every voice be heard, but at the same time, respectful of the process. It allows every voice to be heard, but it also allows us to be respectful of people's time. And on that basis, I would ask that you make sure, Mike, that the Planning and Zoning Committee doesn't take these comments up here wrongly. We greatly appreciate the volunteers in all these committees, the Clean Committee, Clean Community Committee, the Planning and Zoning Committee. Last night, I spent time with the Airport Committee. These are our citizens, right, Mr.

» Webb, who are giving up their free time to to give advice to us so we can act on behalf of a huge 770 square mile county so this these deliberations though heated should not be taken as disrespectful and taken in a positive tone because we're passionate about doing the best possible job we can for that mr administrator attorney mr chairman no legal briefing but we do have two matters for executive session very good I see an executive session here for two items. The first item will require the administrator present in the EDO office. And the second item will require the attorney and his assistant to come. So I look for a motion that we adjourn for an executive session and return. Possibly we'll vote, but it is the intent that we not vote unless there is a call for a vote.

» So, can we have a motion to adjourn for an executive session? Mr. Bozor, it's first. Second? Second. Was that you, Tammy? Mr. Tucker, any discussion? All right. Well, thank you for a long evening, but it was very productive. With that, let's move to a vote. All those in favor, signify by raising your hand. And it's unanimous. And we are adjourned temporarily for an executive session. Second. Tucker, Jones. Tucker, Jones. Any discussion? Seeing there is none, all those in favor? It's unanimous. Let's have a motion now. A motion to adjourn. Second. Second. With who? Gardner? No discussion. Gardner. Let's move to a vote. All those in favor signify. We are adjourned. Thank you. Gentlemen, it has been a wonderful evening. Thank you.