Kershaw County Council Recap Council RecapKershaw County, SC

Read

LatestMapProjectsArchive

Your council

CouncilRoadmap

Get involved

How to be heardSubscribe freeAdd to your phoneSupport the RecapSend feedback

About

ContactAbout the Recap

Full meeting transcript - January 22, 2019

Machine transcript of the county's live stream. Each » marks a change of speaker; the captions don't say who is talking, and names are often misspelled. For the readable version see the recap; the official record is the county's minutes.

» It's a great day in Kershaw County, an all-American county. I think we have time now is 1730 hours, about submarine time. Yes, sir, it is. Mr. Tucker, we have a quorum. I want to especially welcome back Mr. Gardner, who has diligently been recovering from an operation. It's terrific to have you back, sir. We're delighted you're here. Good to be back. Also, we're delighted to see that Camden's elementary school will be ribbon-cut today at 6. We'll probably miss that. I would guess. We had one in the Lugoff area last week, and we're going to have another one this week. It is a great day in this county. With that, I'm going to ask Mr. Bozard to lead us in the invocation and the Pledge of Allegiance. Would you please stand? The gifts from you.

» I just pray, Father, we will treasure them as gifts from God and our Lord. Now, this time we come to do down in business, I just pray that you would be with each one of us. Let us have the understanding that we can do the best job possible for all the people of Kershaw County. For all that we ask in the gate and holy name of Jesus Christ. Amen. The United States of America, public, tax, and nation. Thank you, Mr. Bozardi. And I'll turn to Mr. DuBose to bring forward any public comments. Sir. The first person that signed up is Donnie Cato. Mr. Cato, how many in total do we have signed up? We have seven people signed up. Seven people. We ask Mr. Cato, hey, good to see you. We ask you to keep it to about five minutes, and we'll keep a clock so we can keep this moving along.

» Keep your comments focused on your topic and keep it respectful of this body. I regret to say our procedures are that we don't have a question and answer period, so this is just to hear from you, but we'll make sure we have your contact information so we can follow up with you and anybody else. Please, Mr. Cato. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and Council, for allowing me just a few minutes to speak. I come to you this afternoon with great concern about our fire protection in the northeastern part of Kershaw County. Today on my farm, which is located in the Timrod community, not in Bethune, we have a Bethune mailing address, but we live in the Timrod community. And my opinion, that's one of the greatest communities in Kershaw County, right, Mr. Gardner? Absolutely. Gardner's. base up there.

» A lot of family there. This morning as we were making our rounds on the farm we were fortunate enough to be there and we had a fire in our number seven house in the ceiling of the house. We had a receptacle feeding a feed line motor that had shorted out and had it not been for the fire protect the entire insulation that's in those houses then we most likely would have lost that house plus maybe another one or two. I come to you this afternoon encouraging you, begging you, asking you, whatever it takes to get a full-time person up there in the northeastern part of the county. Perhaps it would be just a matter of moving some resources of a truck band over to the News 5 station. I have to have an addition to that station, but just a truck there with a full-time person.

» Now, we do have a full-time person, but he rotates all over. Now, that person today had to come from Shepherd to come to my farm, and they did respond in a timely manner, did a good job once they got to my farm, and got the fire under control. I'd like to bring to your attention what's in Timbride community. In a seven-mile radius, most of you don't realize that there's an investment up there of tens of millions of dollars, poultry and agriculture businesses. Now just to give you a little respect, but what's there in that seven mile radius is Cal Maine Foods. Millions and millions of dollars to put that operation there. Holton Foods, Holton's Farms, which is a hog operation, faring operation, it raises tens of thousands of pigs per year. That farm belongs to brought Dr.

» Ron Preston and the other farms that's in that area, we have 11 Preston turkey operations there, one Circle S operation. Those farms, when I built my first four houses in 1994, cost me $300,000. I built four additional farms in 2000, four additional houses in 2007, cost me a half a million dollars. When you put all those houses and all those farms together, They're just there in that one little circle. You're not talking about a few million dollars. You're talking about possibly a hundred million dollar investment that we have in that northeastern part of the county. I think with moving the resources around a little bit, we can get a full-time person up there when we need them. I'll give you an example of that, and then I'll sit down because I think you understand where I'm coming from.

» My remembrance, my life, there's never been a deputy that's assigned to the northeastern part of Kershaw County. Sheriff Lee Bone has been in the office a month or two now. He has a full-time deputy, resident deputy, northeastern part of Kershaw County. Nearly every time that I'm out on the road, I meet that deputy doing a super job up there. Now, a sheriff can move a person up there when all the rest of these sheriffs before him couldn't put one up there. using, I think, the same pool of resources of men and equipment. And certainly we can move a person up there to man a truck, and the other trucks can follow once we get one there, knock it down enough that can possibly save a million-dollar farm. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Mr. Cato, very much. Mr. DeVos.

» The second person is Stephen Lee. Mr. Lee. Good evening. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. I'm speaking to the ordinance regarding containers. I am an owner of a container. I'm a pastor on Black River Road. I pastor Mount Olivet Baptist Church now for 26 years. And I've started a cattle operation known as Meanwhile Ranch. And I found that the container was greatly beneficial for me. Mine probably would not even be recognizable as a container because I built a shed over it. But I don't think that everybody should have to do that. My brother was a farmer, and he parked his container behind my dad's house. It's visible from the road in the winter, but not in the spring or the summer. These containers are really helpful.

» I leased land, I leased 117 acres on the Charlotte Thompson School Road from a man that has denied me the permission to build a barn. But I was going to, before the ordinance, I became aware of the ordinance, I was going to ask permission to put a container there because it's the only way I can put chemicals and tools and secure them. I've had a lot of theft in the years that I've been farming, probably totaling somewhere between $10,000 and $15,000 of equipment stolen. And, you know, this kind of stuff just never comes back. Also, the principal of Mount Olivet Christian School, which has been in our community for nearly 42 years, and don't need a container there.

» but I would like to know that on the back edge of the Mount Olivet Church property, if I needed a place to store something, I could have that convenient storage, which is not permanent. I understand that there's a lot of concerns over issues. When I first heard of the container ordinance, I thought of the multiple buildings in our county and city that are nothing but caved-in old wrecks of houses that, from what I understand, are homeless shelters. unofficial and crack houses unofficial. So I know that this is a really big problem but I think that the container is actually a benefit to people that need it.

» Now having said that I understand there are communities that would not want one in there but they I think have covenants for those kinds of issues that cover that and fortunately where I'm fixing to build my house there is no such covenants, so I'll be building about 100 yards from my container, which you wouldn't know to be a container. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Reverend Lee. Sir, Mr. Post. Third person signed up is Angela Huff. Good evening. Yes, ma'am. Good evening. I'm going to speak, and then I want to go see the new school. So I want to talk about the ordinances, the container ordinance. I have passed some on the way here, and they were at construction sites, so obviously people need to use them. I also have one near our farm that, you know, is like Ms.

» Reverend Lee was talking about. It has a covering on it. You wouldn't even know it. But if you put a screening in front of it, it would really detract from what the people have done with that container and that shed over it. And I don't know if you watch DIY, but the shipping containers make really good homes. And they're easy to insulate, and they're easy to cool, and they're easy to warm. And that goes back to, you know, recycling things and not just putting them in landfills. And it also goes to our homeless shelters. If you really want to solve a problem, you could have multiple of these. You can dress them up and make them nice.

» And then when the hurricanes come, they're a lot safer than some of these other buildings and the buildings he was talking about that people do use that are in disrepair. I'm just concerned that it can't be a main structure and how you want to hide it. And hiding things is not always a good thing. And it just gets to be, are you going to grandfather those people in that already have theirs? Because this man, I don't know if y'all know how many containers there are. And I don't know him. I just ride by his house. But it looks very, very nice. And if I had that, I would enjoy it.

» but um with my school stuff but it seems like you're just you go back to what i said last year you first do no harm and that should be your first oath thank you thank you ms ho please mr bose next next person signed up is justin jones all right mr jones thank you evening members of council and county administration it's a pleasure to speak to you tonight um i would like to start my comments tonight by addressing some local issues that have been on my mind of late.

» To begin with, the storage container ordinance, which more specifically, I have a concern with line G, where there is no specific definition of properly maintained, and also line C, which seems to devolve into convoluted language regarding how to conceal the container, as well as relying on the arbitrary opinion of a planning official to ensure compliance. This, as you can imagine, makes me somewhat nervous, as it should anyone who is reading this ordinance. Next, I'd like to move on to the issue of the sewage tax, which I have paid diligently, as I'm required to. But it only occurred to me recently to actually ask what concrete benefit I received from it. When I posed this question to my council representative, I was told, somewhat bluntly, absolutely nothing.

» And that was his opinion, but that was what he said. In fact, the longer we talked about it, the more it occurred to me, in my personal opinion, that it was a slush fund used by this council to fund something that I would call pet projects, for lack of a better term. Finally, I'd like to address economic development, and more specifically, the end of last year when a member of this council did his due diligence and exposed the Economic Development Commission's use of, at best, inaccurate and, at worst, outright fraudulent job numbers with regards to their efforts for creating jobs in Kershaw County. I wanted to personally thank this council member for his diligence and express my concern that he seemed to be alone in his efforts.

» That leads me to the bigger issue of what the job of a local council is as I see it. The job description, I would say, involves protecting the rights of its citizens from usurpation and to act as a united defense and bulwark against outside encroachment of these rights. And finally, to serve as a deliberative body as regards the issues that concern us all. And by deliberative, I mean to introduce, scrutinize, discuss, and debate with open minds and votes reserved until the debate is concluded. As it seems lately, too often for my comfort, many council members walk into this seeming to have already discussed issues, knowing where their opinions are and who is going to vote for what.

» It is certainly not the job of a local council to take money out of our pockets to fund projects that they deem worthy. It is certainly not their job to micromanage our daily lives, nor to equate the will of a majority of the council as being the same as the will of the people in general and certainly not to replace our individual priorities with priorities shared by council members. This led me to considering something that I call the instruction manuals for governance, which includes documents such as the U.S.

» and South Carolina Constitution, the Federalist and Anti-Federalist Papers, the Magna Carta, the English Bill of Rights, the Mayflower Compact, the writings of John Locke, Adam Smith, philosophers of Plato and Socrates, and to ask you gentlemen if any of you have actually read these documents. And if so, and if sorry, and if not, why not? And if you have not, can we honestly say that you have approached this job with a serious heart and have not instead just showed up with a pocket full of good intentions? Thank you, gentlemen. Thank you, sir. Mr. DeVos. The next person signed up is Penrae Gustafson. Mrs. Gustafson. Good evening. I'm Henry Gustafson. I'm here on behalf of Food for the Soul.

» I'm on its board, and I'm an active volunteer, and I thought I would update this council and the public of what we've been doing, what we did in 2018, and some of our plans for 2019. For those who don't know, Food for the Soul is a homeless shelter, and we also provide meals Tuesday through Friday, breakfast and lunch, and scatter meals and distribute meals throughout the county um and i wanted to say in 2018 just in the month of december we served 357 breakfasts 1012 lunches 358 dinners total meals for just december was 1727 and that's a low month um we we assisted for the year of 2018 a total of 104 people, 63 men, 33 women, and 8 children. We do accept men, women, and children. It doesn't matter your age or your circumstance.

» As long as you live in the county or you reside in the county, we'll shelter you, and there's no limit to how long you can stay if you're needed, if you need there. We are also the only shelter within 14 nearby counties that take in men, women, and children without going on some sort of waiting list. So we have sincerely saved the county and its municipalities a lot of financial burden by being able to assist all these stranded individuals or travelers also. Our director, Darlene Thomas, is phenomenal. She is a wonderful woman. Her heart is in it. Their board members are active and involved, and we've almost doubled in size, our board. And we have all kinds of people who come through there. We have people who are not just homeless, of course.

» We have people who are in need of some social interaction. We have some elderly people who come in just to see other people. We have other people who are just really, really tight on the dollar, and they can't afford all the meals in the month. Right now, we are currently serving an 82-year-old man with dementia and a family of four. And this family of four has been spotted in Camden. And actually, I talked with a whole bunch of people online today with one of the public pages about this family specifically. It was really great to hear individuals in the community speaking up. And actually, some people had taken it upon themselves to help this family. And we have been also at Food for the Soul.

» But it's just, you know, I think there's misnomers out there for a homeless shelter because we're so much more than that. We've also hired a social services person who's there four nights, five nights a week, 20 hours a week. That's it, five nights a week. And to take care of some of these extra issues and problems that so many of our patrons have. We are located at 110 East DeKalb, and our number is 432-4771. And of course, when you're a charity and you're helping people, you have to have fundraisers. And we have our annual golf tournament coming up on March 28th, and we are looking for corporate sponsors. Anybody in the room would like to be a sponsor. And also Midlands Gives, which is on May 7th. We are happy to serve this community, and they do an awesome job.

» And Food for the Soul really feels that the organization represents hope and love and respect that is often not received in the outside world for these people who come through our doors. But thank you for listening, and when things come up with Food for the Soul, we'll keep the council informed and the public informed. In fact, I want to publicly thank Jim Tatum for this wonderful article that was in the Chronicle Independent on December 25th, Christmas. It says, not just a soup kitchen, and we're not. So anyway, thank you so much. Thank you, ma'am. Thank you very much. Next person is Curtis Blackman. Mr. Blackman. No, we're not communist-type government, and this type of government tells you exactly what you can do. No, we're not that way yet.

» We may be if we continue to ask for laws to control everything that we disagree with. I do not own a container, but someday I might want to. I would not want to deal with some type of law restricting this ownership. As an example, my wife and I were looking at a TV program on home buying just before I came here. One home the couple considered was in a neighborhood that said no fences. Well, they had a dog. They needed a fence. What do you think happened? Did they ask county council to pass a law to allow fences? No, they went somewhere else. My point here is that we don't need laws to control every aspect of our lives. Concerning containers, if you live in a subdivision, does not want them, they control that. People in any area can control what they want in that particular area.

» We don't need government involvement and laws to pass to do this. Thank you, sir. Mr. DeVos? The last person who signed up is Tom Webb III. Mr. Webb? Well, I wanted to speak about containers too, but something else that's kind of connected with that, and the last fella kind of stole some of my thunder. It's the remaking of America. We see this happening. They're picking on Trump, our president, all the time, trying to do him in, get rid of him, taking down our monuments, turning our young people in the universities into little socialists. We keep getting this long string of never-ending ordinances. It changes the way people think when They are going to submit to ordinances and, you know, it affects their lifestyle and affects the way they think.

» And so the next ordinance that comes along might be a little easier to swallow. It just doesn't look like there's ever going to be any end to it. I object to that. I think it's part of the taking down of America. And I don't know where it's coming from exactly. I'm not blaming you exactly, but I think you're being used to some extent by something somewhere. This sends us these bright ideas that we should have another ordinance. This container ordinance, in my opinion, is stepping on private property rights. There was an attempt to pass an ordinance back in 2016. That's it. It's almost the same ordinance that you will be working on tonight.

» The only thing that's different about it is at the end of this, it says no advertising is to be displayed on the containers and must be free of graffiti, posters, bills, or other deteriorating impacts, which I would consider an encroachment on First Amendment free speech. that if you have a big wall, you ought to be able to put an American flag on it or something from the Bible or vote for so-and-so. It's your right, First Amendment. Well, they took that out. So we have the right to put it on our containers now, if we have a container. Only thing now, you have to shield the container from public view. So, again, they have undone our First Amendment, our right to have something out there that we say, look at this, I'm proud of this, look at what I'm saying, look at my flag.

» It's just another one of those attempts, I think, to do something good that really is not a good thing at all. And I know where this is coming from. Somebody on council slipped me some paperwork. I can't tell you who, but somebody did. This is it, the comprehensive plan from about 10 years ago. It's like 300 and something pages. Now, we have more openness now. People can find out what's going on. You can look online and you can find it. Back 10 years ago, you couldn't do that. If you wanted to know anything about what's in this comprehensive plan and you didn't know where to look, you would go to planning and zoning and they would charge you 50 cents a page for 300 pages. That's $150 for somebody out in the boondocks to come into Camden and get a copy of the comprehensive plan.

» And I don't think comprehensive plans is the way to go at all. It's a it's a way to snow the people. They don't know what's in it. So I found in all of this stuff, I found the sentence where this this idea of a prohibition on containers comes from so it's right in here and i was if i can you know lost my place now might be here all night trying to find what i'm looking for to read through all of this stuff i think i marked it with a little piece of tape see if i can find it there's one little sentence and all of this 300 and something pages there's the tape turn it over i should have brought a trash bag to put all of this in it's where it belongs we say that we have a there is a uh an ordinance that that prohibits something but it's not been prohibited apparently hasn't not been prohibited

» because people have had these containers forever and uh there has been no prohibition so it's not a valid law it's been sorry sorry here we go here it is i finally found it sorry for using up your time that way um privacy and direct decorative fences and walls are permitted along the property line of any lot or parcel in compliance with the visibility requirements of this section. All fences and walls used as part of the buffer area requirements must have a finished side that is facing the adjoining property. The interior side of the fence or wall may be finished as owner deems appropriate. That means that if you live next door to your mother and you want to put up a fence, your side of the fence can be rough, but her side has to be finished. But that's not what I was looking for.

» I'm sorry. That's just another incidence, another an example of this overbearing government that wants to tell us what to do. It's micromanaging our lives and we don't need it. We're Americans. You know, these young fellows, these Catholics that were verbally assaulted recently, y'all know that's in the news and the media wanted to play it one way when in actuality it was another. And there was a Vietnam veteran there, American Indian, who was in their faces trying to get some kind of bad reaction so it could show up on camera. He didn't quite get it. These young fellows looked out for their decorum. They did very well, these young Catholic fellows. Not all of them were white either. And they were being accosted by something called the, what is the, the black Israelis.

» News media, news media, again, is on the wrong side of everything. But let me, out of all of this mess, I have found the sentence I wanted to find. Out of all of this mess, it says, the use of mobile or manufactured homes, shipping containers or similar structures as accessory buildings should not be permitted in any zoning district that's all there is to that i think it's a bad law it's not a law it hasn't been it they haven't been prohibited it's nonsense and all of this belongs in the trash it's the wrong way to do government thank you very much thank you mr webb uh mr debose that concludes the sign-up list very good and that concludes public comments we'll move now to adoption of agenda can we have a motion to approve the agenda make it mr chairman i'll make a motion to approve the agen

» da very good a second please second second for mr gardner welcome back mr gardner uh discussion i would point out that there will be two executive sessions tonight the the first one before the administrator's contract and we'll adjourn briefly and come back for a vote and the second one at the regularly scheduled executive time and we'll come back and probably not vote um uh any further discussion yes sir excuse me mr chairman i was under the impression that we were going to have both executive sessions at the end of the meeting well the idea would be we could do that but and i'm certainly willing to to forego an executive session before we vote on uh mr carpenter is it the view of everybody here that we need if i may if i may and then we can start right here for somebody else you know i've

» been on this council 13 years and And the reason, and Mr. Tucker, you know this as well, we held the executive sessions at the end of the meeting. It's one, the folks that got here at 530 made a trip here. I don't think it's fair for us to go back there where there's 15 minutes, 20 minutes, 30 minutes or an hour and cause you to have to wait. Secondly, the people that are watching live streaming, the people that will watch the reruns of live streaming, I just don't think it's fair to them.

» i would like to see us maintain and continue to have the executive sessions both of them you know at the end of the meeting so we don't inconvenience the people here and also the folks that are watching i'm happy with that any other discussion that we'll have a single executive session but we will proceed with a vote on item number one correct is everyone happy with the point of order say yeah is that a form of a motion or we don't need we don't need it we don't need it i just want to say good then we'll leave it as it's written and i won't declare an executive session uh with that we can move to a vote on the agenda as written fair enough with that we move to a vote all those in favor mr chairman if i may there will be an executive session to discuss the administrator's contract but it wil

» l be at the end of the meeting just as we will i think we have a ethic issue we have to discuss that's correct yeah so we'll just have two issues to deal with in our executive session which we'll do at the end of the meetings and then you want to come back and address item C, tab C. Oh, is that what you're talking about? Right, that's what he's saying. Oh, okay. Then I think that would be a bit of an amendment, would it not? We're moving the administrator's vote to the end. Is that what you're saying? No, sir. I don't think he would call for an amendment, but we can certainly get a clarification from the county attorney. This is to discuss contract and executive session at the end of the meeting, so we're not putting everybody out sitting and waiting. Okay, very good.

» In other words, you're just going to skip item C when you go down, and then we roll out into executive session. That, to me, is an amendment of the agenda. Well, now it's a clarification of the agenda. I think the chairman probably has the inherent power to reorder things under new business. You couldn't change them, but I think the chairman, unless somebody calls for a point of order, and Mr. Snodgrass mentioned that. So looking around. I think unless somebody calls for a point of order, Mr. Chairman, you could move number C to the end of business. Very good. So we shall do that and announce that intent during this discussion. Any further discussion? Okay, seeing there is none, let's move to a vote. All those in favor, signify by raising your hand.

» And it's unanimous, and we'll do that just as you all have laid out. With that, we move now to approval of minutes. I note that Mr. Gardner was not present at the last one because of surgery. Can we have a motion to approve the minutes as written? I make a motion, Mr. Chair, that we approve the minutes that are submitted by Clerk to Council, Ms. Mary, and thank you. Thank you, Ms. Mary. second second for mr connell and any discussion and seeing there is no discussion we move to a vote all those in favor signify by raising your hand and it's unanimous with mr gardner abstaining we move now to a series of ordinances uh first reading of an ordinance by kershaw county to amend a code for zoning and land development it's at tab b and it's also up on the screen mr Mr.

» Carpenter, can you introduce it? Mr. Chairman, members of the council, we have in front of you tonight first reading of an ordinance to amend the existing ordinance related to shipping containers. It comes to council from the Planning and Zoning Commission, which voted in December. Very good. Can we have a motion to introduce it? I believe that's introduced by Mr. Bozard. Yes, I do have this for discussion and a vote. Very good. Can we have a second, please? Second. I'm sorry, was that you, David? Yes. Yeah, very good for Mr. Snodgrass. Do you want to lead in the discussion, Mr. Bozeman? Thank you. This is the same motion that last week we had a little disagreement on between our agenda and some other issues. But now we've got it straightened out.

» This container, as we stand right now, is not allowed in Kershaw County. If you've got them in your land, they're illegal. It has been at least one case that I know of that the container had to be moved off the property. because of the neighbors complaining about it. This motion, as we read it right here now, was at my request from Planning and Zoning and Mr. Carpenter to rework it so we could allow containers throughout Kershaw County. What we have on the agenda here tonight is the results of Planning and Zoning and the Planning and Zoning Board. This is what they presented us to county council. This time, Mr. Chairman, I'd like to read what has been presented to us. Tipping containers, this is under Section 3, 2.53 and H in parentheses.

» When conditionally permitted by Table 3.3, General Development, Rule Development 1, Rule Development 2, MRD 1, the use of storage containers shall be governed by the following. Tipping containers shall not be used as a principal use or construction. Shipping containers shall not be located in front of any principal building or structure. Shipping containers shall be permanently screened from public view. Screening shall be accomplished by a divide not less than eight foot in height. Screening may be accomplished by the use of slight obstructions, plant materials, general level green, earth berms, walls, fences, proper setting of elements, building placement, or other design techniques approved by the planning zone. Shipping containers shall not be stacked.

» Shipping containers shall not be located in any required side or rear setback areas. And I'm going to have to ask Mr. Cornell about that one because I didn't think that, I mean, Michael Connolly, because I didn't think it was allowed to build in any setback areas anyway, and I don't understand why that one's in there. The number of accessory shipping containers shall not exceed one per lot, except where the building to which it is accessible exceeds one acre, then an additional shipping container may be established for each acre, provided they meet all the requirements. Shipping containers shall be properly maintained at all times.

» This is the way it is right now, and I'm going to leave this right where it's at right now because at the next voting, the next meeting, I do have a motion to change some of this in there. Okay. Just to see if I can understand it, this law now exists. This is not putting in place a new law, but amending an old law. Is that correct? That's right. And it makes the law more, it relaxes the law. So on that basis, you've introduced it. Yes. All right. Very good. Other discussions? Maybe from the second, Mr. Snodgrass or anybody? Yeah, I wanted to speak on the reason why, second, first of all, you know, the way the county government works, you have several readings and we get this on the floor and it enables us, county council, to further have discussion with constituents.

» Personally, as I see it, I realize that while this is not an active, enforced ordinance, it is indeed an ordinance. And I have friends, folks in my district who do have shipping containers. And from my view, this is providing citizens the liberty and the freedom to be able to have this. Now, I will say that what's coming to us from planning and zoning is a little, you know, it's a little too restrictive for my taste. But the beauty of county government is that we're able to make changes. The public are able to come and you're able to give public comment. I mean, this is not the statehouse or federal government where it takes years to get things done. We're able to tweak and make changes.

» So I believe this gets us on the right road to providing liberty and freedom for shipping containers for homeowners should they deem that's a decision that they want to make. Okay, thank you, sir. Other comments? If I may, Mr. Jones. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of county council. Let me start by saying that I oppose the ordinance that's in front of us tonight. Therefore, I intend to vote against it. However, I plan to present an ordinance that repeals the prohibition against storage containers at a later date. In other words, counsel is right. There is a law that does not allow storage containers. But what this amendment does, you want to talk about convoluted bureaucracy. It is very confusing. I would like my, so I would say to Pastor Lee, Mrs.

» Huff, Justin Jones, Curtis Blackwell, and all those others that got up and spoke. My proposal will absolutely eliminate the ordinance. It should not have been in there. And I spoke with someone today who was on the planning zone commission at that time, and it was not a unanimous vote whenever they voted in that storage container ordinance. And bottom line is this will fix it for everybody. In other words, let your HOAs, your homeowner associations, handle it. And if we see that it becomes a problem, we can always go back and readdress it. But my recommendation is we wait, we send it back to the Planning and Zoning Commission, and we ask them to repeal the existing ordinances on the books that does not allow storage containers. Let me say this. Let me finish.

» I'll say this to some of you who have storage containers. Don't think this law may protect you. You better make sure because some of you may be in violation based on this amendment that we're doing. We don't know. But this amendment alone brings a page and a half of a lot of regulations, and it's going to lead to more and more and more and more. And I know you agree with me, Mr. Tucker. So having said that, I would like to hear from my colleagues. But that's what I plan to do. Mr. Bozard. Mr. Bowles, you might be able to help me out. I don't think this has to go back to the planning and zoning. It can be handled right here if we wanted to do that option. Is that correct? Well, it's got to be germane to the ordinance.

» ordinance for you is to um mend those regulations for accessory structures and uses so depending how the up how it's um structured and i don't know that it could be broadened this this ordinance could be amended and brought amended right so as long as it's germane to the caption which is regulations for accessory structures and uses as long as the amendments germane to that it can be I don't know what the amendment is, so you're asking me a hypothetical question. Is that the way you see it, Mr. Jones? No. Are you speaking about my proposal? Yes. No, my proposal would have to go back. Would you give clarification on that, Mr. DeVos? Well, my recommendation to eliminate the container law. Well, the container law now is under 3.2, 5.2 general requirements.

» says the use of mobile home shipping containers cannot be permitted as accessory buildings. I think the ordinance, as written, could probably be amended to strike the requirement that shipping containers cannot be accessory buildings in any zoning district, if that's what you want to do. But, I mean, you have other things involved, too, but I don't know how... There are other requirements as to accessory buildings, correct? I mean, accessory buildings have other requirements, don't they? Can you come forward, Mike? Mike, if you allowed, here's a question.

» If you allowed a storage container to be an accessory building, are other requirements in the zoning code, are there not, that deal with accessory buildings? For accessory containers, we don't have any other compounding restrictions on accessory structures for shipping containers because they're not permitted. Yeah, but if you take them out of that sentence. If you just take them out of that, you're generally going to allow them throughout the county with no restrictions. No restrictions. As to number or use, or the overriding districts would restrict the use, wouldn't it, for instance? You couldn't use them commercially. Correct. I mean, if you keep them up under the accessory use itself, then they would have the same restrictions that an accessory structure would have. Correct.

» Unless you just restrict that out altogether. But I think Mr. Jones wants, I don't know what exactly the amendment is. I'm having a little bit of a difficult time here. But Mr. Jones says he wants to repeal restrictions added to accessory buildings. Is that not correct, Mr. Jones? Correct. Well, let me just make sure I understand this there, Mr. Jones. Let's look at paragraph D. It says mobile or manufacturing homes, shipping containers, similar structures as accessory buildings shall not be permitted. So you want to strike them all. No, I do not. that's not what I said. I said storage containers. Yeah, that's good. I wanted everybody to understand what the nuance that Mr. Jones was using. This is not just a shipping container ordinance that we're trying to amend.

» This is for a larger range. So you heard what Mr. Jones said. So I'd look forward to seeing how you and Mr. Bozard would want to amend this thing. Okay? Is that helpful? I think that's what you're trying to get at, right, Mr. Jones? Mr. Chairman, yeah, we're pretty close on the same page here uh basically bottom line is i want to appeal any restrictions on storage containers throughout kershaw county and i don't know that that would mean striking the whole we we wouldn't have to strike the entire ordinance or the entire line we could just strike that one title which is storage containers and that's what this amendment does but let me can i ask again another point sure i'm just trying to get clear on this there are people who are calling me asking that this restriction be removed okay and th

» at's in favor of the amendment there are other people who say they want to tighten it up so we have we've heard from the a large number of people who have and here tonight who are against any restriction but there are some people who are landowners who want to protect their property how do you get that issue is my question sir here's here's my position on that based on the folks that i've been speaking with and it's been a large number of folks i believe that we should not be regulating every single thing people can do on their properties i think this is a deregulation i think it's a good thing i think that it wasn't an issue i've been here 13 years i think i've had two complaints on storage containers and they were handled i can tell you now this amendment passes that mr bozar has put on t

» he books there's gonna be some enforcement on storage containers and let me let me go along going to mention this too. This is limited use of storage containers only in maybe three or four different zoned areas, not anywhere in Kershaw County. So if you wanted to get a storage container in certain areas of Kershaw County to store some product in or store some stuff in for a period of time, you would not be able to do that. I'm saying there's some HOAs, these neighborhoods that protect them. We don't need to regulate a law telling people everything they can do.

» I can assure you this amendment that's on the floor now is very confusing setbacks covers blinds you know i just simply want to uh repeal and delete the storage container yeah let me let me be clear here though uh let me take a prerogative as a chairman just for a second just for clarification we we agree this is not as this ordinance is not a storage container ordinance is wider we agree that this language that takes out shipping containers should be done but i'm trying to find the word storage containers in the ordinance could we ask mr for clarification on this i'm just telling you as a fact as i read the english here in front of me it's shipping containers well shipping container but it's different from what the language we've heard from our public here tonight that storage containers n

» o i think it's semantics i think yeah but it's semantically important when we're trying to change the law mr dubose you've been here since there was dirt here can you tell us what this what this is all about mr chairman the ordinance before you yes does remove shipping containers of being prohibited and then it provides performance requirements as to using shipping containers but it does require shipping containers the people that spoke did call them containers storage containers yeah and i've heard the councilman here tonight use the word storage containers uh shipping containers to me represent those sea lion vans that you see down in charleston on the back of those big boats and their ships right mr tucker but uh mr bozart can you clarify what you're trying to fix here i'm talking about

» shipping containers storage containers i know nothing about i'm talking about the ordinance right now that says no shipping containers will be allowed in the county and so the complaints we've heard tonight are storage yeah mr john mr mr chairman let's listen to mr jones yeah i'm gonna make this easy for you clear it up because i this is getting ridiculous a little bit to me but anyway bottom line is the things that these folks were complaining about tonight is shipping containers where you call it a shipping container storage container bottom line we're talking about the same thing and uh i don't think there's any confusion there with me we're talking about the same thing whether you say storage container or shipping container bottom line i want that i want to repeal that and that well i w

» ant to repeal the prohibition against any storage shipping container that's mentioned in the current ordinance mr jones i'm gonna i'm gonna refer to mr bozart here in a minute mr uh debose we'll go right ahead i do you can read it three times then have a public hearing i might add but i think if you just left section one in then addressing mr jones here and took section two out mr connolly you amended the ordinance and left section one in and by amendment took section two out what would be the effect of that that would prohibit in the allowance of shipping containers in our county that would let 18 wheeler shipping containers that would allow them that would address mr jones's issue assuming he just wants to allow them correct yes i mean if that's what he was looking for i would have to rea

» d the language mr jones yes you could amend this ordinance by leaving section one in amend it take section two out that would unconditionally allow shipping containers but mr debose if i may now mr mozart's got the lead now please go ahead i would like mr but debose not to make legislation here tonight okay thank you sir let's look at the regulation he didn't i think he was explaining it to us pretty good thank you mr bows let's look at the ordinances on our agenda item d right there under three two five two general requirements y'all should have a line through shipping containers do you have a line through it there it is drop down to three two five three that is the stipulations of shipping containers if we deleted that whole section three two five three we would get rid of everything woul

» dn't we mr we would get rid of shipping containers right that would be the opposite you would allow shipping if we deleted if we deleted that's three two five three that's what he meant that would get rid of all shipping containers right that would allow them that's what he's asking that would get rid of all all restrictions yes that would that would take care of everything wouldn't it if we would delete that leave it in that item i i can't comment on what you mean by everything here you deleted section two of the proposed ordinance well no Wait a minute. Let me get ready to call a point of order. Both gentlemen have indicated their desire to bring before prepared documents for us to see in two weeks. Well, it's three weeks now, 12th of February.

» And in the interest of moving the discussion forward, I don't want to get into legislating here, but I think our questions are being answered so that you all can come in on the 12th of February with an amendment. Let's let Mr. Connell speak. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and council members. First question is, any existing shipping container would be grandfathered or non-conforming. Is that right? Would there be any retroactive impact of, just assume this passes tonight and it makes it through three readings. Is there any retroactive impact for existing shipping containers? In the form in which it's presented? No, I mean, again, we don't actively enforce. Would it be a non-conforming use? We passively enforce our zoning ordinance.

» Would it be a non-conforming use for something that pre-existed the code? Now, that's tough because under the definition of non-conforming, it means it had to have been at one point in time legally established, and I don't believe you would have to go back and look. We would give the benefit of the doubt to the property owner, of course, that we traditionally do, but it would have had to have been at some point in time legally established. Right, well, if the government hadn't taken away those rights, that right would be retained to the people. You know, I looked at, I think this got on in the books in 2010 when the unification of the code came about. I couldn't find it in the older ordinances. So, again, you know, we're talking about something prior to 2010. Okay.

» And then another question, Mr. Chairman. I don't mean to gum this up further, but maybe it's just how I read it. So under D, which has shipping containers deleted as a proposal, assuming shipping container stays in there, By implication, as I read it, you can't use it as an accessory building, but it could be used as a primary building or some other primary or principal structure. Is that right? Yeah, I mean, what we've done traditionally with the primary structure is that we don't really regulate what a primary structure is, per se, of living in a residence. Building codes have traditionally done that. We go by the 2015 International Building Code, and it's pretty tough to amend a shipping container for it to be a legal residence. You have to have wiring certain distances apart.

» You have to water a certain distance apart. You have to have the insulation. You have to have holes into it, so then there's structure differences or questions. I'm not an engineer, so I don't know what those are. But, you know, when you happen to put windows in these structures, because any residence has to have escape mechanisms and have to have windows. So, you know, there's a lot to it that you really have to start getting into when you actually have to make it a habitable structure. So we've always traditionally leaned back on that when we talk about could it be lived in. And there's a different code for commercials. There's a whole other code that goes under the commercials, and different states have different ordinances they go by. So, you know, it's hard to go from state to state.

» Well, under the code as it exists now, I'll just assume that that 2015 building code you referenced would allow for shipping containers to be used if they met up to certain standards. Yes, sir. I actually thought about using shipping containers to build my house at one point when I looked at the structural integrity. I've got a friend down in Charleston who actually has a house that's made out of two that are stacked, ironically. So as I read it now, you could use a shipping container for your primary residence under existing law if it met up with the standards. One second, Mr. Bozard. I think he just confirmed for us if a shipping container meets the building code requirements, you could use it as a primary structure or residence, but not as an accessory building.

» I think that's a fair reading of my interpretation. Mr. Bozard, let's keep it in time. So he's asking the question. If I could finish the thought, as the law sits now, we could use it as a primary structure or principal dwelling, but not as an accessory building for storage, which is kind of ironic. I think that's a little bit funny that you could use it for your house if it met certain standards, but you could not use it as a storage unit. The only thing I can think of, and not to cut you off, the only thing I think of is when it was written, they probably weren't really used regularly as a resident. They probably weren't even being really thought of as a resident eight to ten years ago.

» I'm sure, I mean, whenever I was working in Charleston, I'd see, you know, however high they stack them, eight or nine, and somebody got the idea one day, wow, that's really strong. I could probably make a house out of that. That's a fair reason. So they probably didn't think about putting that in the ordinance at that time. Sure, sure.

» As far as I'm aware, we don't really have that language in the ordinance prohibiting that we just always relied on the point is the the engineering and the development of it has come a really long way and the speaker that stood up tonight is quite right i mean they're some of the most beautiful architectural houses you'll see if they're done the right way so the the amendment as i read it would encourage using it as a storage structure a storage unit in effect but prohibits you from using it as a principal structure which is allowed uh under the code right now so i think while it's very well intended it's still quite confusing.

» And, you know, no pun intended, but I think we're ships passing on some of this stuff where we're trying to allow shipping containers, but unintentionally restricting it being used as a principle. And for that reason, I probably can't support it tonight. I didn't get the clarification I was seeking. Okay. It's Mr. Gardner's turn. You know, I think as of right now, you can't have shipping containers. Is that right? As of today, you cannot have them. Is that correct. I don't know if that would override what Mr. Connell is saying about as an accessory building. Well, right now you can't have them, period. So I don't think that would apply to a primary structure either, but that's neither here nor there. I don't agree necessarily with this.

» I am willing to vote this along tonight because number one, it will allow you to use shipping containers and it will allow more discussion further down the road. That's why I will vote to move this forward because as of right now, if you have shipping containers, you're in violation of the law so i'm going to vote for this to move it forward so that so that at least it will allow you though there are some restrictions on it it will allow you to have them and then we'll see what mr jones presents or whatever amendments come down the road but i will move this forward because it will allow us to have those shipping containers for use whether primary or accessory or whatever so because right now it is if you have them you're in violation of the law as it stands as I understand it.

» And just to hear from everyone, Mr. Tucker. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, my colleagues. I'm of the opinion, as Mr. Gardner just stated, of trying to get this back to the agenda and moving it down the road. I do have some issues, Mr. Connolly, with this. One being, I think this is a written ordinance with good intention but bad results. I'm just being honest. It's just, you weren't even here in 2010, So no pun intended on you. I may be a Democrat sitting up here, but I still believe in people's liberties and rights. But I also want to have a conversation with you and Mr.

» Carpenter in reference to how many complaints did we have? Did we take one or two complaints, which is the minority, and create something that we did not need to create in 2010? How many people now are in violation? And what I mean by that, you know, I know that the ordinance is in place, but if we pass this as we've gotten it now, how many people we're going to affect where they're not going to be grandfathered in and they're going to be put in a bad situation. Those things I'm very conscious and aware of and I don't want to create. And I say that with all good intent. So what I'm asking my colleagues and I to do, bring back your amendments and let's set out. I think Mr. Jones has a good idea. I don't know if I would go to the exact stream where he's at.

» But I don't want to interfere with people's rights on their property to a degree. Now, if we've got an issue or a serious problem out there, then we need to address it. But, you know, people don't change the speed limit just because one or two people think it's dangerous on that road. It takes a vast majority. And I don't want to get this government into tweaking things for the minority few, very few, and hurting the majority who doesn't have an issue and abide by the regulations and ordinance we have on the book. What I'm hearing from all of you is a further consideration of this document. We're trying to relax the regulation. Let me offer this for discussion just to keep it moving.

» We've agreed to come back here and on the 12th and address this should we have a work session because it's fairly complex As mr. Webb showed it 300 pages But in this case we want to stay focused on the issue that mr. Bozart has brought Would you guys agree to a brief working session? Comments mr. Jones. I just want to kind of go back to a couple of things that were just mentioned when this is what? concerns me. When I have my colleagues who say these were good intentions but bad results, but yet they're still going to vote on first reading, that concerns me. We don't need to move this along. I think this is very convoluted, very confusing, deep regulation. I think it's going to cause us more problems than not.

» And as I said, I want to present an ordinance, and I think you would have to go back for the planning and zoning. Am I correct on that, Mr. Bozard, not to repeal prohibition against shipping containers? Mr. Bozard asked me if, I believe, if you could have Section 1 and not Section 2. I believe that's what you asked me, didn't you, Mr. Bozard? Mr. Bozard asked me the question, could you enact Section 1 and not enact Section 2? Did you not ask that question? And to answer that, Mr. Bozard is, and Mr. Jones, if you enact Section 1 but don't enact Section 2, then shipping containers would be used as an accessory building, accessory structure and use in Kershaw County, just like any other accessory structure and use. Isn't that correct? No other restrictions? Yes, sir. My understanding.

» I'd rather like to believe in language, but sure. I agree with you. I'd like to see the actual language. But Mr. Bozard queried that, and his answer to that was, yes, Mr. Bozard, if you enact Section 1 and not Section 2, than shipping containers would be accessory structures and uses, period. To finish, if I may. Go ahead, Mr. Jones. Just to finish. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of county council. 2010, one of the speakers got up and held up a thick book, a thick page of regulations, and that one sentence or a couple of sentences were in there.

» Well, bottom line is I voted against that entire package because I thought that was absolutely over-regulating without a 2010 whatever comprehensive plan so i didn't support it then and i certainly don't support this now this is not complicated we just repeal the prohibition against shipping containers mr chair made the people yes sir mr talker the property two quick things and wait a minute i'm sorry you're still talking to go ahead please i'm through now thank you thank you mr talker um if you want to do a work session can we have this where we can maybe extend some of this retreat time coming up we meet before um we have our next council meeting um this is uh as one of our members that said very convoluted and i think it needs more time and what i would like to do now is call the questio

» n so we can move down this agenda and then we can have further discussion in our work session after that we call the question can we move now to a vote yes all right all those in favor of the amendment which strikes the language shipping uh the use of mobile or manufacturing shipping containers or several structures as accessory buildings shall not be permitted in any zoning district scratching shipping containers all those vote and that on the first reading voting signify by raising your hand we have myself mr. Bozard mr. Gardner mr. Tucker mr. Snodgrass in favor on the first reading all those opposed on the first reading Mr. Jones and Mr.

» Connell the motion passes and moves to a second reading with that we move to the next item on the agenda which is new business which is the administrators contract it's at tab C and on the board I'll introduce it because it's the administrators item you'll notice in there we have made some correcting language on tab C let me turn to that very quickly and at the salary location in paragraph four on page one of three. It strikes 158. It strikes the previous number and reflects the pay rise voted in December of two and a half percent. We move to page two and there are no corrections. We move to page three. Excuse me, Mr. Chairman, item six. Yes, of course. Thank you very much. Where is that, Mr. Jones, Mr. Tucker? On the term of contract of the year.

» six six yep on page two it extends it for out to the period of two years to 31 december 2020 went right by that and on the last page it corrects the date of signing and execution uh with that can we have a motion mr tucker um to approve yes i'll make a motion that we approve uh this contract for uh the kershaw county administrator big carpenter uh second please Second. Second from Mr. Bozard. Discussion? Yes, sir. Mr. Tucker will lead off. I thought we were skipping this until we came out. That's where I'm going. Oh, yeah. Oh, my mistake. So I didn't want to cut you off, but yes, sir. I withdraw that. I withdraw my motion. Thank you, Mr. Tucker. And withdraw your motion. Move to item number two. Fire service solutions and accomplishments. This will be of no vote. Tab D.

» You have a number of read-aheads. Mr. Carpenter, can you lead off? Members of Council, 2018, an ad hoc committee was established to review fire service in Kershaw County and to come back with some conclusions and recommendations. When the staff and the various subcommittee meetings were done, there were several recommendations and conclusions that were presented to Council. This is back toward the end of last year. We are now coming, at the request of Council, back with the final conclusions and recommendations to present to Council. It is the intention to present those and then open the discussion for the next several weeks and months as we go into planning and goal setting and the budget itself. Mr. Scott Wiles will be the presenter of the information to the council tonight.

» When it comes up, you have also, in addition to the presentation that he'll be going over on the screen, you also have in your packets and was presented in front of you addendums that are substantiating information. They do not change anything. They are just the drill-down data that were used in many cases to come up with conclusions and recommendations. Okay, very good. So no voters required, and we'll give them feedback and then have a subsequent session on this. Please, Chris. Good evening, counsel. I've got my professional clicker over here. He's going to help me. Like Mr. Carpenter said, we've put this together. These are some of the recommendations and stuff we had back in August, 1st of September. These are some of the things we've worked towards and where we're at at this point.

» Many recommendations. These are the eight items here at the top. These are the big ones that we went over or that kept getting brought up and brought up and brought up. So we're going to go over these eight items here as we go through. All right. Divide the county into districts. It kept being brought up. So on September 10th, 2018, the county fire service was divided into four districts.

» the next slide here is the map basically shows your outlines no district lines were messed around with or anything like that we just kind of condensed those individual stations into a district kind of tighten it up get us where we are so we can get tighter numbers and see where the call volumes and where our services are needed and stuff a restructure county fire service ranks from top to bottom fire marshal is now the chief deputy fire marshals the deputy chief chiefs are no longer in the stations. It is a captain. He oversees the station operations, his personnel, and his equipment. In the book there you've got attachment one, goes over the qualifications for those officers from the captain down to the support firefighter. Also includes classes they're required to have and so on.

» Three, the training standards countywide. Training schedule will be finalized January 31st. It's actually on my desk right now. We're trying to get it finalized and get it out there we've got a meeting on the 28th um but getting that together and that all pertains to iso which is an insurance service office national fire protection association and occupational safety and health administration um along with county fire service uh lugo fire and candle fire last year would you want to come together to try to get more fire academy classes brought into kershaw county for our volunteers um attachment two that's a list of fire academy classes that were brought in last year like i said between us lugo fire and candle fire we we got those classes brought in here and had instructors teach us um atex

» kind of its own thing but we did between those three organizations we did help a tech out teach classes um with their live burn test out and other things involved with that for standard operating guidelines january 1 Updated and issued the standard operating guidelines to all members. These, previously we would print out a copy for everybody and go on and on and on. It is now inside our emergency reporting in the library where everybody has a digital copy, and it can be updated when it needs to be. Restructured 1% funds. 1% committee has been formed. It consists of three volunteers and then myself and Christy. For the volunteers, they're going to be serving a two-year term.

» After two years, we'll get three more volunteers from outside the county come in and we'll continue doing what we're doing purpose of the budget um quick question are those staggered terms for continuity no we're just being as small as we are the three and then i'll go into three more that way i don't have i don't want to get into well nobody's representing my area nobody's representing my efforts one percent comes from the state fire association yeah for example first first term would be one year for some people and in others it would be two years so that you you have continuity yeah very good possibility we do it like that stuff around yeah let's look at that one all right thank you of course uh attachment three in there that is basically the one percent it's through our uh firefighter as

» sociation it's from the insurance service offices where we get a little money back for doing what we're supposed to do our training trucks up to date and stuff that kind of goes through the guidelines rules and regulations what we're can and can't do with that money for six built a new plan for recruitment and retention this was a big one it kept getting brought up, developed recommendations for volunteer point pay increase in the 2019-2020 budget. We continue the supplemental workman's comp, also recommended changes through our 1% fund to help the recruitment and retention, the active nominal for all firefighters, supplemental retirement plan, and specialty training, which the specialty training does not involve anything through the South Carolina Fire Academy. Yes, sir.

» changes to the 19 and 20 budget. Will that be then presented to us or are these subject to a work session? I'm just trying to schedule this body to take this on. That particular one right there was actually put in for the 2019-2020 budget that's going to be presented. Okay guys. Thank you. Number seven there. Standardize the equipment list to get everybody on the same page. When we utilize the ISO, which is the Insurance Service Office, there are equipment lists that we need to have on these trucks at these stations to get our ISO rating. So as nozzles, hand tools, and hose goes out, the proper stuff will be put in place and we'll continue with that list so we can keep a better eye, keep our ISO rating and eventually go from there. Number eight, reporting software.

» Computers have been purchased and they're installed at all my 12 main stations. So every main station has a brand-new computer. It is in rotation with IT in Kershaw County, so if they need maintenance, if they go out, they'll be taken care of through there. Emails are also put in place at these stations to do away with the fax lines. Yes, sir. That fire department up on the Lugoff side of the lake, is it all equipped with everything except manpower, right? Yes. As far as the computer and stuff, too? Yes. No, the computer is only at the main stations. Okay. Any plans of putting anything up there? Risk of getting it stole, probably? Do you have anybody going up there and staying on the weekend and stuff like that? Okay. From this reporting software, data collected that we've gotten so far.

» This is kind of the breakdown we're going to go, starting off with the breakdown incident types. These are all in your slides, so we'll go over these one by one and go from there. Breakdown. These reports also, this is what I turn into Mr. Templer every month. He sees these quite frequently, so he's with me on them. Basically, this is a breakdown for the whole county here. I can't break it down further, which you'll see in some of your attachments there. It actually breaks it down into the districts, into the stations. This goes over the type of calls that we respond to. You can see right there the Rescue and Emergency Medical Service one. That's basically our first responders, and it includes motor vehicle accidents and stuff like that. That's our big call taker.

» Further breakdown was on attachment four. This one here goes into the districts. District map I showed you earlier, District 1, 2, 3, and 4. This also has Camden, Lugoff, and Other, which Other meaning outside the county. These are times that they've called for us, and it breaks it down even further right there. Your district, District 1, Blaney, Pine Grove, and Dobie Mill, they're the front runner. Of course, the outside, like Lee County, whoever, offer mutual aid. So we're going to break it down even further. This breaks it down into the individual station in that area, from Antioch all the way to Buffalo. The headquarters down there, that one throws you off a little bit. That's just times that myself or Keith have been tied to a report, and it shows that we were out there.

» One of the other ones I found was good information for us, hour of the day. When these calls happen, what part of the day? And I want to point out to you there, between that 1 and 2 o'clock time frame, I don't know if it's everybody trying to get back from lunch, trying to get an extra couple of minutes or what, but call volume jumps. It just gives you an idea of our timeframe throughout the day, about 24-hour period, where the call volume is. These charts are very easy to, I can get those charts in. This one here basically breaks down that one you just saw, the hours a day. Now it puts in average personnel. I mean, personnel do you get for that hour a day on these particular calls? And you can see our numbers, where they range out there.

» From anywhere from the lowest one on there, I see is 1.88 to a total of 3.63, I do believe is the highest one. Or 8, 3.86. So that just gives you an average person, that's for the whole county, for all the calls that we had from this time frame, the 319 to 1231, 1,349 calls. All right, and this is just another part of the report that will break it down even further for us on some times. Of course, top up there you can see first responder rescue calls, fire calls. Then you get into the dispatch to arrival. That's from the time the dispatch hits the tone to the first truck or personnel gets on scene and tags on the radio. Then the next section there is the dispatch to en route time. That's the time from the dispatch until somebody goes en route or they get a truck to get en route.

» Is there a standard? Yes, sir. Based on our area right now, it's based off the NFPA 1720. And for what we have, it's for 500 citizens or 500 people in a square mile, they want you to shoot for a standard of six firefighters on scene within 14 minutes. 14 minutes. Six firefighters. That's certified firefighters. That's not just everybody just showing up, all right, cool, we're here. Six firefighters. I guess we'll eventually get to how many times have we met that.

» standard and i mean we didn't very very few that wasn't okay i have a question yes sir deputy chief wiles and fire marshal um ray thank you so much for everything look you guys do so much with so little no question about it however i'm concerned about mr cato come to here he poured his heart out he presented some information to us about his area of the county yes and and uh you've done everything so far reorganizing within the parameters of your of the fire districts you know in kershaw county let me ask you this how would you address his situation currently we're going to get to that in just a minute wonderful would you make sure we point that out yes okay yes and i mean as of right now to go along with that just a brief thing because let me say this too one commitment that we made and i k

» now mr connell and mr connor remember this that if we were going to do anything extreme with personnel or funding, we were going to do a question, a referendum question, and take it to the people and present it to them. So I just wanted to bring that up. Go ahead. Yes, sir. All right. Conclusions of our data. Conclusion one, we need to continue improving our recruitment and retention for volunteers. That's still, as of this moment, that's 100% of what we depend on. So this will ensure the response times and number of firefighters respond to rural incidents stay within that nfpa recommendation which was at nfpa 1720.

» despite adding paid firemen volunteers are still the crucial component of what we do recommendations for volunteer recruitment um as i said earlier the 2019 to 2020 budget requests an increase for the points paid from 75 000 to 100 000. um one percent funds drafted budgets will include supplemental retirement a specialist training active number one increase volunteer recruitment efforts through station signage we do signs throughout different stations also county electronic signs we've got several that we've put up over the last couple years periodically let's figure something up throw on there and also show some media research for possible grants for recruitment attention it's getting into another realm it's there's some stuff out there for that We just haven't tapped into it yet.

» Inclusion two, adding full-time firefighters. Let me go back. Yes, sir. Amy and I ran into a guy who had experience in North Carolina, remember? Yes, sir, I did. And in North Carolina, some of the counties permit waiving fees and things of that nature. Is that one of the options as an incentive, as an offset? The only incentive as of right now that the state offers, we don't do any kind of offering. They offer a VFP program. Basically, they have to meet a certain amount of training hours, a certain amount of call volume. Oh, that's a killer. And they only get a $3,000 tax credit towards them for the whole year. Mr. Chairman, if I may, the council can offer any council-imposed fees the council could then collect.

» Yeah, we discussed that, Keith, about two weeks ago, right? And can we also ask you guys to bring that forward, some fees that might be waived that we as a county impose. It won't be a lot of money, but it would be an incentive, and it shows a signal of our recognition of their service. Mr. Chairman, can you expand upon on fees so everybody who wasn't in the conversation understands what you're talking about, please? Well, I really asked you all to come back with some ideas of how we might, on a revenue-neutral approach, have some fees waived for those who are volunteers and maybe even full-time manning to increase the incentive for them to volunteer. Now, I don't know what that full list of fees that we have as a county, but they're all in the budget, and you could take a look at those.

» I think there's some road fees and other fees of that nature. This is not waiving taxes. This is waiving fees. Can you kindly look at that and come back with some ideas? I'm asking you to expand the domain of what we can do here. All right? Would you think about that? Thank you. Okay. That 1% fee that comes back from the state, how much money is involved in that? Usually when they send it over here, the state sends it to Kershaw County as a whole. And therefore, Camden gets their cut out of it, Lugoff gets their cut out of it, and then the rest of it. I'm talking about just our fire service. Just our, Kershaw County's fee, after our dues and everything are paid for all our firemen, I think it's roughly $68,000. How much? $68,000.

» And there's only three things that can be used for, right? It's very limited of what we could use it for. Yeah, retirement and. Retirement's one of the big things. Okay, thank you. Brought up. Mr. Tucker, sir. Let me, I want, and I know what you charged the administrator with, but I want to go a little step further because I want all kind of ideas. In that conversation was also, they did talk about some property tax release, like we give out veterans now and homestead. So I don't want to leave that out if it's going to be a new wave of attracting, because this training is so intense and takes away from people's 40 hour a week job that we have to find new ways to recruit and retain these folks.

» And I think that we might be on the cutting edge of doing something different in South Carolina and Kershaw County than um any of the other 45 counties are doing and this individual was from North Carolina as the chairman said so um let's let's explore it and council it is going to be on the agenda at the um planning retreat as well we've got an hour set aside to discuss this again as well as getting into budget work sessions there's a whole lot of time to go over these issues and get them solved yeah as I said it's the purpose here is these seven gentlemen understand what your issues are and then you hear back from us i think that's happening uh please go ahead all right conclusion two adding the full-time firefighters to the um two phases that is concluded low number of firefighters and r

» esponse times exceed the standards our story earlier what we're dealing with hiring full-time firefighters to begin coverage for citizens of kershaw county one is to lower the response time and move towards meeting the nfpa 1720 for adequate personnel to respond to six certified firefighters within 14 minutes. This is for a rural area of less than 500 citizens per square mile. So those are the standards we're trying to push towards. Those standards. Yes, sir. Deputy Chief, those standards would require six additional new firemen. No, you'd be able to work it within your confines of your budget. If I may, standards he's referring to would require at least six respond to the call. Currently, we're not meeting that standard.

» Recommendations will give some on adding full-time that would allow us towards meeting it. We can't rearrange our existing structure and meet these standards because we're not meeting the standards currently. So his standards are national standards that we're not meeting with our current structure. How many pay do you have right now? I'm slotted for eight part-time guys. You have got eight part-time? All eight.

» Those eight slots, those are made up of full-time firemen so they work 24 48 somewhere else and they come here and pull eight hours to work for the citizens of kershaw county and some days today for instance i only had two that were available to work rest of them were on shift or working overtime for their their paid careers then they're covering two or three stations at a time yes sir yeah as he said or y'all heard earlier i had a guy from shepherd and the other one was charlotte thompson he just had to be in here grabbing some materials from the office today and we sent both of them that way thank god wow can't afford to rely on a policy that relies on luck and mr cato's barn's on fire right house house no this is a turkey barn oh okay same thing yeah that's a house okay all right recomme

» nd uh recommended solutions this is where we get talking into the bread and butter of this um 24 hours with our station over in blaney i've got room in there of course there's going to be some other things that come along with this and we're not also also be having our part-time positions still available to help backfill these and add where we need to um the three shift supervisors just to give you kind of a comparison ems's shift supervisors they run the whole county they take care of the manpower staffing needs throughout They kind of take that load off of myself and Mr. Ray, plus some other things they can do. The six firefighters, that's two firefighters per shift, 24-hour shift. If they worked 24 hours, they'd be off for 48. There's holidays and all that stuff involved in there also.

» Just those six for right now, this is what it's going to cost us, and those six would be strictly 24 hours at the Blaney Station. The four firefighters you see up there would work in pairs Monday through Friday, 8 to 5, and I would use them as pairs to roam districts on the east side along with a couple spots for the part-time positions that Monday through Friday. So we would have four full-time firefighters east of the river. The daylight hours, which is thrown back to the chart, was when we had the greatest need of people on duty. We would have 24-hour firefighters, landing stations, along with part-timers as well on the back side of the river. For additional 800,000? Yes, sir. So that would be an additional $800,000? Yes, yes, this is additional to what our current budget is. Mr.

» Chairman, if I may, and that in itself is what we said we would put a referendum question together and go out. So that's perfect, I mean, to take that to the people, and it may be a special election, and we could do that. Mr. Chairman, one point I want to draw out is this is a very reasonable approach to a need that is national. It's not just Kershaw County where growth in certain areas is outpacing fire service needs.

» it's all over the place particularly as the training requirements get up to 200 hours or plus is that what it is just to go to get to a firefighter one just firefighter that's not counting driving trucks or anything else it's 240 hours if you're trying to get david or myself who have kids and are younger and going to be the next generation of firefighters how are they going to take 200 plus hours throughout a year and provide for their family unless they have some type of incentives so it's not that also the fire mill is important here even if we wanted to and we said hey, we're going to raise the fire mill to the maximum amount. That means the fire-related tax, the maximum amount. I think, by law, the most we could raise it would be $66,000. I think that's what we looked at last year.

» Is that right? It's the Act 388. It's like .0485 or something. So the most we could do is $66,000. That doesn't even pay for really one fireman, including benefits and everything. So that, you know, we may have to have the backbone to actually say, we're going to look at the fire mill and try to take care of the volunteers with some of the more proper reimbursements and recruitment stuff and then send it to the voters, as Mr. Jones has said, because we can't do anything else. Because if the fire mill is raised to the max and it's only $66,000, that doesn't even give us one fireman. And you've set a plan up that shows we have a significant need based on call volume, the actual data.

» And so I just wanted to draw that out and say, you know, we couldn't raise taxes legally to even come near covering this. So the voters are going to have to decide whether they want to apply to a house or a car or, you know, how they want to pay for it, one, if they want to, and then, two, how much they value having their call responded to whenever something catches on fire, for example. And you've heard some comments tonight that I think would suggest we want to make the investment. What's the value of the fire mill now? I want to say it's about $110,000. As close to the school districts? Yeah. Yes, sir. No, not the mill, but the value of it. Yeah, right. That's what I was asking. So potentially you could... You could be looking close to 8 to 10 mils. Absolutely.

» That would be for the people. Mandated. All right, and this one here shows what the 24 hours, which, like I said, where we're at. Yeah, you're just shy of a million dollars. Yeah, the top section there is just salaries. The second section is gear, uniforms, radios, cell phones, pickup truck for those supervisors to be moving around with. I'm going to have to be periodically reoccurring. Yeah, the bottom one, yes. A set of gear is rated for 10 years. Okay. So 10 years, they're interior certified. It's got to go. I've got to put them in something new. Uniforms, you're looking at a yearly thing. That pickup truck, that could go for five years. It could go for 10 years. It just depends. And how rough they are. Yeah. And, of course, handhelds, we're learning some new things about that.

» So I'm hoping that this is going to be our last one. At least it is. He keeps telling me that R word. He's not going anywhere. Thank you, Jimmy. Thank you. As you can see, that's total there. This is an altered solution that I came up with. This strictly goes more along. Both of them are that hub and spoke concept that we keep talking about. This one here strictly goes with the 8 to 5 Monday through Friday. The two supervisors during the day, one for each side of the river, and the eight firemen to kind of split up and use how we need them wherever the call volume's at. Same concept here. Top part of it's souring. The bottom part of it, there's implantation of gear, uniform, and stuff like that. The total is $775,000. The only thing is that's cheaper. That's a cheaper solution.

» You don't have 24-hour coverage anywhere in the county. It would be pretty much just building off of what we have right now, and it would be unlike where we've got now with part-time. They might be here. They might have had to work, something. This is going to put something in that position. Mr. Chairman, if we may, I think we have a wonderful opportunity here with a retreat coming up February the 2nd, I believe. We could actually set a goal for ourselves to come out of there with a decision on where we're going to go. Exactly. That's the whole idea. No more. Correct. Good for you. Yes, sir. Absolutely. David. You can go back.

» Well, and you may or may not be able to cover this, but if we talk about upgrades to actual stations, I know in my district, the Antioch station needs repair and needs a lot of work. I'll come up here and set the second phase part. Go ahead, Dan. All right, secondary phase, basically. We're not going to do this all at one time and be happy. Here we go. With that recommended solution, the second phase, we're going to look at the 24-hour daylight shift, increasing the firefighters at Blaney starting off there. We know that's where the growth's at. but also reviewing the call volume, east side, determination of location of a 24-hour station on the east side and start putting in guys like that. And, yes, with station renovations and stuff like that, we're getting bombarded with them.

» They were built back in 74, correct me if I'm wrong. A lot of them's been through a lot of hurricanes, and most of them were block buildings and been added on to over the years. So that's something that we'd have to consider moving forward is just like we do with our trucks, every so often being able to replace one here and there. With the alternate solution up there, the hub and spoke, you're increasing your daylight positions, and we could even take it up to seven days a week, but it would still be that daylight, eight to five, just a different option to look at. Maybe there's a map on the next one there. Yes, this is based off the 2030 vision plan. It's actually 2020 population density projections. You can see where the population is moving. The Blaney area is booming.

» It's starting to come over from Richland County, but you can see it's starting to. We're projecting it to go towards Antioch, Shepherd area also, along with Pine Grove and Dobie's Mill. So we can be moving people where we need to. But as those numbers go up, that population density goes up, it changes what we need to be shooting for on getting guys on scene. 1720, I believe, once it gets above 500, it changes from six firefighters in 14 minutes to 12 firefighters within 10 minutes. So, I mean, as the population grows, those standards start changing. All right. Very good. Thank you very much. Mr. Chair. Wasn't that great? Go ahead. I just want to say thank you to the committee again, Mr. Gardner, Mr. Connell, and Mr.

» Jones, especially thanks to staff and these two gentlemen here for such a good job of getting back with us and giving us some numbers, and I look forward to some of these solutions and creative ideas. Okay. Other guys, other comments? That was great. I echo what Mr. Tucker said to Mr. Gardner and Mr. Connell and Mr. Jones about getting the data. Wow. That informs us wonderfully. Let's move now to item number three, which is a Health Services District Board appointment at Tab E. I'll introduce it. We have a vacancy that developed with the departure of Karen Eckford. We have had before us in the last meeting the name of Kathleen, Catherine Candy, also endorsed by the members of the Kershaw Health Services District, and we look to have her nominated. Can we have a nomination for Ms.

» Candy? So moved. Mr. Jones, a second? Second. Second for Mr. Tucker. That was Mr. Snodgrass. That was Snodgrass? Yes. okay you guys look so like uh can we have uh any discussion mr jones or anybody no discussion i think you cleared it up pretty well yeah what did you say her name was miss canty catherine canty her husband is owns the foundation specialists in town and she is quite active in the in the county all over the place so i've talked to her about it and she's more than willing to take it And Daryl Ogburn, the chairman, recommends her. This is the snow cone man's wife, right? No, this is the foundation man's wife. Okay, that's a sister law. Other comments? Okay, we move quickly to a vote. All those in favor, so signify. And it's unanimous, and Ms.

» Canney is now on the Health Services District Board appointment. I will point out to you that maybe other movement there I've been talked to by at least one other that may pull off. So I ask you to keep your eye on that. very important uh board that helps us out so much item number four is a discussion regarding patriots landing at tab f uh i'll introduce it and then no vote is needed here but we may come away with an opinion for a letter right mr jones correct so it's been uh as you walk around all of us got we've had six months six weeks of incredible rain 10 inches in december alone And upstream in the watershed, it continues to have a problem with water that comes down through 10 different dams above us. And occasionally we've had to close down the Patriot Landing.

» We've gotten numerous protests from hunters and fishermen and people that just like to be on the river. And so I thought it would be appropriate in discussing with Mr. Jones and others that we review the policy and we also perhaps address it certainly uh what i view to be a hazard uh with the dock that is downstream of the loading dock uh which causes equipment to include trailers and boats to go underneath and swept by the current underneath the dock itself so with that open for discussion i'd certainly uh go to mr jones sir mr chairman i think this is pretty cut and drop from my viewpoint uh i've received many complaints when the landing was built the pier was put there the dock was put there it was supposed to be a break to keep the current from going up under the dock absolutely well th

» at was taken out due to money obviously but it was in there they had it budgeted but they took it out of state for some reason whatever our responsibility of that is that we we volunteer to go down there to keep it up to date if uh i guess potholes or whatever am i correct yes sir what i would like to see and what i and you and i've had this discussion i'd like to ask the chairman to write a letter on behalf of kershaw county council demanding the state to go and do what they did not do somebody's gonna die somebody's gonna get killed at that landing i've seen boats go under we've i was kayaking and uh we sort of had a race and I was winning, and we got down to that section, and someone's boat just went right up under the dock. We had to jump out and help him pull it.

» Of course, he almost went up under the dock as well. And when the water is high, it's actually safer to put your boat in than when it's down to normal levels. So that would be my request, Mr. Chairman, if there's no opposition. I'm not asking for a vote, just if there's no opposition verbally, that you write a letter on behalf of us uh mr tucker uh mr chairman and my colleagues um quick question because i thought we've already always had a great report with um the state um it's just nothing that we've addressed mr carpenter already uh maybe with dnr i know the the the local dnr guys is a local young man here um matter of fact he lives right up the street here um that probably got us in the right direction and along with DOT. And, I mean, have we exhausted all those leads is my question.

» Mr. Tucker, really, as the chairman said, up until our recent levels of rain, we haven't had too many issues where the landing was closed or anything. Recently it's been closed a lot, and that's kind of drawn attention to it. As far as I'm aware, our relationship with DNR is strong. It's good. So I can't imagine that they would be at all unwilling to point us in the right direction or certainly consider a request, we haven't made one. So upon making a request, I'm sure that they would take it and act upon it in some fashion.

» I just didn't want to get into a letter, not saying the chairman would write a bad letter, but let it be misinterpreted, let's use those words, and then we've got ill feelings going back versus having maybe a conversation or a meeting because it's hard to ask someone to fix something that they're not aware of that is a problem. Mr. Jones? First off, they are aware. And second off, I was going to write a letter myself, and I was going to hit the head straight on. This is dangerous. Somebody's going to die. And I'm just saying that even though we don't have any responsibility of that, that the chairman sent a letter. Well, the chairman and I talked, and I just felt it may be better coming from the chairman representing the whole council instead of me sending it by myself.

» But if we don't do that, I am going to send one. Well, we all can write our own individual letters. I just don't want to start off on the wrong foot. That is my indication of how bad conversations turn to no conversations because we don't have good conversation from the start. And so, you know, we're all up here, elected bodies, elected individuals for one body that can write a letter anytime we want to. I just want to be cautious on what we say in that letter if we're asking council to be supportive of the letter of the chairman writing one and that we do make sure that we communicate clearly with them on what the problems are.

» Now, you may say that they're notified and they know, and I'm not doubting you on that, but does the right people know? Have we talked to the right folks? And let me just say this, too. The chairman on our behalf writes a letter. I have not known him yet to not share that information with us before it's sent out. He's always been very good about that. I'll be happy to write one and take your edits, sir. I think Mr. Tucker is just suggesting that we extend, the letter extends the olive branch to begin. Yeah, well, okay. Thank you, Rep. Yeah, thank you, Reverend. Mine was not an olive branch. I think we get a consensus that we have a problem, and we'll work collaboratively with DNR and others to get it done. All right? And I'll share with you the draft.

» i can write it tonight um with that uh i think we move to council briefings and led by mr bozard thank you uh danny thank you very much nothing uh nothing from mr bozard mr connell if you felt a slight rumbling in the earth blue golf and camden are wrestling probably right now and uh i'm just itching to get over there yeah me too well i want to see that one nothing to report I think we've had a good season so far with both teams. Jimmy. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of county council. Just a couple of things right quickly. One, I just want to say that one of my very best friends is here tonight, Austin Branham. Thank you for coming. You can stand up. Austin and I go to lunch about once a month together, and he doesn't let me forget it.

» And his beautiful mom and wonderful, I won't say beautiful, dad, Stacey Branham, they allow him to spend some time with me. And let me just say this, Austin Branham helps me be a better person. Thank you, Austin. I really appreciate your friendship. And he's got a bow tie. And he has a bow tie. Now, let me just say, let me move on. I have just one other thing. At the Economic Development Summit that was organized by the Kershaw County Economic Development Office, I stated the fact that Kershaw County has not been successful in getting new industries and industrial economic development.

» An economic development expert spoke at the summit, and I asked, why hasn't Kershaw County been successful in getting new industries and industrial expansions? I asked the economic development expert, what can Kershaw County expect to get in 2019 in industrial development? The economic development expert, who was paid $4,500 to give a one-hour talk on how Kershaw County measures up, could not provide concrete numbers in my response to my question of why Kershaw County has not been successful over the past 10 years in economic development, our new economic development. Folks, we need answers, and I am requesting that the administrator make a report to me and Kershaw County Council of what Kershaw County can expect in 2019 as new industries locating here.

» At the Economic Development Summit, we heard that we had many site-ready industrial parks and a mega site, and that the Department of Commerce and the electric co-ops are actively and aggressively marketing our sites nationally and internationally. I also request that the County Council set goals and expectations for the new industrial investment numbers and new jobs for 2019 so the citizens will know what results they can expect for the $4 million in Economic Development Office budget for the past four years and up to $31 million committed in a $17.2 million bond for economic development from the taxpayers, which was enacted by county council in 2015. I am committed to economic development, which is essential for jobs and our tax base.

» Over the past year, I have pushed for transparency and provided transparency as to the cost of economic development to the taxpayers and a lack of effective economic development. Folks, that is a fact. We now need accountability to the taxpayers as to results and cost. Huge spending on economic development requires results, which we can have through redirecting our efforts. What we're doing is not working. Let's market our great site-ready industrial sites and our unique mega site and recommend by the taxpayers, I mean, that was recommended by the experts at the Econaut Development Summit through the South Carolina Department of Commerce and the electric co-ops developing the Megasite is the top priority, as we heard at the summit.

» And if I may say that I have over the past six or seven months entertained y'all with my comments on Econaut Development, I've always concluded with when something happens, it's going to be the Megasite through the Department of Commerce. And also, I think the expert mentioned something about 15-acre sites would be good. Well, we've got plenty of those. We've got maybe one over in Heritage. We've got a couple, maybe one or two in Steeple. But I think we, at the Governor's Hill site, we have a few more. But there are things we can do. And I'm looking forward to discussing this goal setting with our administrator at the retreat on February the 2nd. Now, one second. Chairman, Members of County Council, thank you for the time. Thanks, sir. Mr. Snodgrass, sir. Mr.

» Chairman, members of County Council, just a couple things that I wanted to note. And first of all, ironically, Penry is here talking about food for the soul. And it was already in my notes to mention, you know, with the weather the way it has been, I'm reminded of just how blessed those of us are who have a roof over our heads, but also blessed that we live in a community that has organizations like Food for the Soul. They had 11 sleeping there last night and had as high as 22 last week. So I just thought it was important just to mention those resources that we do have in our community. I also wanted to just kind of expand upon my vote on the ordinance.

» I explained earlier that I believe that county government is the best form of government because it is the most local and is the closest to the people. If we don't get it right, it's very easy for us to kind of turn the screwdriver and the tap of the hammer and make those corrections. And I believe that my vote was a vote to move us forward in the path of deregulating that. I don't believe everything that was in that ordinance was perfect, but I do believe it moved us forward to deregulating that. So I wanted to share that. I want to thank county staff who continue to work with me on some constituent issues. So thank you guys, executive staff. You guys continue to amaze me with your responsiveness. And then lastly, yesterday I attended a service in the honor of the Reverend Dr.

» Martin Luther King Jr. And as a pastor myself, I look at his life and I admire a man of faith who got involved in the public square. And as I was at that service, I was reminded of just how important it is for us to see the world through someone else's eyes, to take a step back. And when we get so zealous about issues, when we get so passionate about things that concern us, there's certainly nothing wrong with that. But I would just encourage us to be mindful, to see life through someone else's eyes, to think about what it might be like to walk in their shoes. And I'm convinced that our dialogue, not only locally, not that we have a big issue with that, but certainly our dialogue on a national level would change drastically if we took time to see the discussion from the other perspective.

» Thank you. Mr. Tucker. Thank you so very much, Mr. Chairman. I won't keep you long. I just want to dovetail off of Councilman Snodgrass's remarks, and I want to say thank you for all who attended. It was several of our council members up here, several people from the county that attend, well-attended function. Over 300 people showed up, and I can say this. I'm not afraid to say it. Y'all can write it, whatever you want to do. These programs aren't let's beat up on white people. OK, it really is a program where you can get true and good information. And the message yesterday was Luke 6, verses 27 and 28. And it's just states that we ought to love people, love our enemies, love our folks that are indifferent from us. And that resonate throughout that church.

» Ben, if you think about you and Councilman Bozart, some good singing, y'all missed it yesterday. They brought the clouds down and the heavens. And that place was rocking. So I thank all who was in attendance. And we had our sheriff there and his staff. His chief was there and his captain and many other elected officials. The chairman showed up and always shows up. And I appreciate that. And for you other ones, I challenge you again next year. You get a letter every year. That concludes my report. Mr. Gardner.

» Just briefly, I'd like to thank my colleagues on council and our staff administration for all the calls and cards and meals and everything she did while i was out uh convalescing i certainly appreciate it especially the meals uh but i do thank you it's so good to work for uh people that keep you in their prayers because prayers really go a long way i just want to say thank you publicly thank you very good uh i'll close out and and then we'll do some other business uh some housekeeping first of all welcome back mr gardner secondly uh mr carpenter will take us through some of the particulars of the retreat uh but i will tell you we had 950 thereabouts responses thank you mike thank you sir to the vision 2030 survey we are hearing from the people and the people are reading our stuff ben and gi

» ving us feedback sometimes they're telling us to stick it in our ear and other times they're not but we are receiving the feedback we need from the we the people um i heard a bit about um well let me just skip that and go to digitization i'd like to hear from mr debos a little later on about digitizing digitizing our ordinances and so on so they can be readily available and so i don't have to have mr webb coming here with 396 pages we can get it off the off the web from mr for mr webb and others like him um chairman as a chairman i would work met with the treasurer the auditor the administrator and the assessor you have letters that we sent to the company that was supposed to do our tax notices and they made a few mistakes i'll ask your patience but we'll work through that the people of the

» county need to know that we're doing everything we could to get the tax notices straight but we have to rely on contractors like every other county in this state and the contractors let us down um i will close out on the economic summit all of us are for more economic development uh i would close out with what i got out of the same conference that mr jones went to uh i got the quote that's also captured in the chronicle independent of hold the course you're doing it right number two if anything do more and do more aggressively so what i've asked uh and we may differ on that and i think it's certainly different with some of the ideas mr jones has and look forward to the discussion and the way to do that is as he suggested and i suggest that we go into the retreat ready to roll up our sleeves

» and then have a separate work session. But we're doing all the right things, and I believe we can refine our course as has been suggested by all you councilmen at the retreat and at the work session. Mr. Carpenter, please. Chairman, members of council, just a few items. Mr. Tucker, last night you also said This won't be but a second before you start your comments. I've been there for two hours. Council retreat is Saturday, the 2nd of February. It's going to be a full day at the Economic Development Office. We will be holding it starting at 730. Don't forget the Friday event, please. Yes, sir. I was going to. Running from 730 until 430. The public and the media are invited. The night before, we'll be having dinner. Council members getting together to plan and go over.

» as well as getting a chance to introduce Mr. Snodgrass to them as well. And then you have in your possession a survey that has been given to you, asked to fill it out and return it in advance of that. If you will fill that out, it makes it a lot simpler in getting everything ready for the day itself when we start getting into what each one of you – no, sir, that's not the survey. The survey is put in your boxes. And so if you take it home, fill it out, and return it to Mary, we've done this for the last couple of years, so it should be very familiar to you once you get it. That makes it a lot easier to set up the day for you, so it can be a very productive day. Also, the public will notice that there is construction now going on in the upstairs sections of this building.

» We have almost finished downstairs, and now we're working upstairs and getting offices renovated, carpet replaced, courthouse as well as over here. and various buildings updated for the first time in 20 years. There you see just basically upstairs what you would see if you went up the stairs, where a few walls, some of them are security being put in. Finance will be behind a security wall. Some of the areas, HR and some of those will be put into more private areas. They will not be behind security walls, but they'll be more secure, so citizens and the public who need to come in will be able to have their issues handled in an appropriate setting. And, Mr. Chairman, members of council, that's my report. Mr. DeVos. Mr.

» Chairman, as you delineated previously, I believe there are two matters for executive session. The first one is on the new business seat, administrator's contract. And then the second one is I would like to give a legal briefing on a contractual dispute that involves an elected official. And those are two separate items? Two separate items. And they have no relation to each other. In other words, we're not going to – it doesn't relate to Mr. Carpenter's contract. No, it does not. No, it did not relate. And I believe, of course, you'll – I believe you indicated Administrator's contract. You might take action. The other one, you would not. Yeah. Can we ask that we have Mr. DuBose and Mr. Carpenter join us, and we'll adjourn.

» So can we have a motion to go into executive session and to return for a vote on the Administrator's contract? So moved. Mr. Bozar, a second? second for mr gardner discussion uh everyone we will be back after this uh discussion it may go long it may go short and we will have a vote when we get back all those in favor signify by raising your hand and it's unanimous and we are temporarily adjourned let's go yeah motion to come out executive session second please uh discussion who did you give a second i don't know second came from mr gardner no discussion we move to a vote all those in favor signify by raising your hand and it's unanimous and we move now to the item on the agenda we deferred which is the administrator's contract tab g and also on the screen thank you danny you're way ahead an

» d just to recite the changes were to update to the two and a half percent pay rise page two has a date change uh for the scope and period of work and on page three has a a date time group for when the contract would be executed can we have a motion to approve the contract as amended So made. Mr. Bozard, second from Mr. Connell. Any discussion? I would just tell you we got the best administrator in the state. Mr. Chairman, I'd like to make a mimp now. I'm going to shoot you. We have the best administrator in the state. And we've got the best county council in the state. One of the best benefits of having Vic around is Laurie's around, too. But anyway, this now gives us the way to go forward. And I will ask for your vote. All those in favor, signify by raising your hand.

» And it's now unanimous. And with that, it passes. And we move now to a motion to adjourn. I make the motion to adjourn, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Tucker. Second. Second from Mr. Snodgrass. I'm named killing you tonight, Mr. Chairman. Got the twins down here on the right. That's what you get for messing with me, see? All right. Any discussion? Thank you, gentlemen. It's been a long night, and it's been very productive. with that we move to a vote all those in favor and it's unanimous and we return you all be safe going home thank you